Outline of Position Items
Position/Basic Facts
Misconceptions or Tabula Rasa. Cant think of too many
misconceptions here and would expect students to have a reasonable
understanding of the point concept and to understand what the
coordinates of a point are. The main purpose of this material is to
connect to something the students are familiar with and establish
common ground from which we can depart together into less familiar
waters.
- Begin
. Still to be done. A video or cartoon that
illustrates the importance of position, the idea of a target. Could
be illustrated with bow and arrow shooting and landing a spacecraft on
the moon. Tool Tip: "The role of position in trajectories and
targets".
- Explain It
. Still be done. Have a simulation that
lets you draw a point, move the point, draw a pair of axes, move and
rotate the axes, and that will display the coordinates of the point in
the form (
,
). It will be easy for students to accept
that we require two coordinates to represent in point in 2-d, three in
3-d. (Position vectors are not introduced at this time.) It will be
explained that a point can be thought of two ways: geometrically
(graphically via a dot) and analytically (via numbers). The
geometrical concept of a point is something absolute, the analytical
description is relative to the axes chosen. The simulation will
illustrate this. The 1-d case is also introduced. Here, we have only
one axis, whose direction and orgin can be chosen arbitrarily. Tool
Tip: "Points and their coordinates"
- Simulate It
. Still to be done. The Simulation from
Explain It by itself. Tool Tip: "Points and changeable
coordinate axes".
- Test Yourself
. Still to be done. Question on analytic
description of a point and its dependence on the axes vs. the
geometric invariant property of a point. Tool Tip: "Points are
absolute and coordinates are relative."
- Get Information
. Still to be done. Summary of the main
ideas from Explain It without the simulation, but maybe a graph. Tool
Tip: "Points and their coordinates".
Position/Position Vector
Misconceptions or Tabula Rasa. The latter in this case. Position
vector is a new concept that needs to be introduced. A misconception
that can arise is that position vectors are like other vectors and can
be added or scalar multiplied. It should be made clear that that is
not possible so that position vectors are not really vectors, only
look like vectors and for that reason share the name. They are
displacement vectors attached to a given point.
Should we very briefly mention the notion of "position
space" as opposed to other spaces, e.g., "velocity
space"? Position space has two kinds of elements: points and
displacement vectors. Mathematically, such a space is called an
affine space. Its structure is distinct from that of a vector space,
for which velocity space is an example. These spaces can be easily
distinguished from each other because their elements have different
physical dimension.
The material under Position Vector requires Displacements as a prerequisite.
- Explain It
. Still to be done. Use simulation from
Position/Basic Facts/Explain It, but modified so that students can
draw vectors in it as well. Have students draw a displacement vector
from the origin of a pair of axes to a given point. Call this the
position vector of that point and show that its scalar components are
identical with the coordinates of the point. Explain the notion of
"trajectory", with simulation showing position vectors to
points on the trajectory clicked by student.
Have student click two points on the trajectory: system will show
the two position vectors and the corresponding displacement vector.
Adding the displacement vector to the first position vector gives the
second position vector. One obtains the displacement vector as the
change (difference) of the two position vectors. Generalize to
difference of vectors. Use components to work out the difference.
Refer to Vectors and tail-to-tail construction of difference.
Tool Tip: "Points, position vectors, trajectories, changes in
position vectors".
- Simulate It
. Still to be done. Use simulation from
Explain It. Tool Tip: "Points and position vectors".
- Test Yourself
. Still to be done. A couple of
questions on notation (components of position vector are denoted x and
y), position vectors and displacements along trajectories.
Displacement vectors as difference of position vectors. Tool Tip:
"Position vectors, notation, trajectories".
- Get Information
. Still to be done. The content of
Explain It without simulation. Tool Tip: "Points, position
vectors, trajectories".