![]() |
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
"Attempted Suicide" Incidences/Risks Suicidality Studies From 1970 to 2009 |
![]() |
Qin P, Agerbo
E, Mortensen PB (2003). Suicide
risk in relation to socioeconomic, demographic,
psychiatric,
and familial factors: a national register-based
study of
all suicides in Denmark, 1981-1997.
American Journal
of Psychiatry, 160(4):765-72. (Abstract) (Full Text) - "...registered
[same-sex] partners included as a separate
category
in the analysis had an odds ratio of 4.31 (95% CI=
2.23–8.36) in the crude analysis and 3.63 (95% CI=1.71– 7.67) in
analyses with adjustment for other factors in the
full model
[for having committed suicide compared to
opposite-sex
married couples]". Note:
This is a First-Time Research Result! See: Frisch M, Bronnum-Hansen H (2009).
Mortality among men and women in same-sex marriage: a national cohort
study of 8333 Danes. American Journal of Public Health, 99(1): 133-7. Abstract. After 1995, higher risk of death in same-sex marriages occur in first 3 year of the marriage. Note:
The paper does not mention the Qin et al (2003) suicide results
(above), and suicide is only mentioned as possibly being implicated in the higher
risk of death for same-sex couples.
Review Papers & Meta-Analyses: GLB Suicidality & Mental Health
| Categories |
Random |
Non-Random |
Non-Random |
| American |
Adolescents in Schools: 1, 2, 3 A - A4 |
Youth / Adults 1970-1983 B 1987-1991 B-1 |
Youth / Adults 1993-1999 2000-2009 C - C4 |
| American |
Youth/Adult - University Students D-D5 |
Adults 1994-2009 E - E3 |
Dissertation Studies F - F2 |
| North American |
Adults G |
--- |
--- |
| Canada |
Adolescents in School: 1, 2 |
Youth |
AIDS/HIV Male Cohorts |
| UK/Ireland |
--- |
Youth/Adults (England/Scotland) H Youth/Adult (Ireland) |
--- |
| Europe |
Youth/Adults I - I2 |
Youth/Adults J -J3 |
France K Austria L |
| Australia New Zealand |
NZ Birth Cohort M |
Youth/Adults N-N2 |
--- |
| Japan, Mexico & South Africa |
-- |
Youth/Adults | -- |
| World Special Samples |
--- |
USA Twin Study NZ Birth Cohort / USA Longitudinal: School O - O3 |
--- |
| Colorado, USA |
Three Studies |
Three Studies |
--- |
| Selected "At Risk" Populations |
Psychiatric Patients |
Street Youth: USA / Canada / UK: 1991-2006 |
Transgender P -P5 |
|
|||
Rothblum ED (1994). "I only read about myself on bathroom walls": the need for research on the mental health of lesbians and gay men. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 62(2), 213-20. (PubMed Abstract) Full Text.
Semp, David (2007). A Public Silence: Sexual Orientation and Mental Health Services. Presentation, Mental Health Awareness Week, 2007: Mental Health Foundation of New Zealand. Word Download.
Semp, David (2006). A public silence : discursive practices surrounding homosexuality. PhD Thesis. The University of Auckland. Download Page. PDF Download: Front Pages. PDF Download: Whole Document.
"Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Transgender Students: ... There is no concrete information about suicide rates among gay, lesbian, and bisexual (GLB) college students and little to no information about efforts to promote their mental health or prevent suicide. There is even less information about the behavior and needs of transgender students, though we can assume they face somewhat similar risks...GLB students who transition from high school to higher education may bring some of the same suicidal behavior to their new environment. One study attempted to measure the suicidal risk among a small sample of GLB college students compared with a sample of their heterosexual peers (Westefeld, Maples, Buford, & Taylor, 2001). Researchers administered a paper and pencil assessment of suicidal risk called the College Student Reasons for Living Inventory (CSRLI). GLB students were more depressed, lonelier, and had fewer reasons for living than a control group of their peers, and depression and loneliness correlated positively with suicidal tendencies. In addition, GLB students in this study experienced prejudice and related issues (Westefeld et al., 2001). Many campuses are increasingly open to and supportive of inclusion of GLBT students, but homophobia remains a problem..."
Note: In 2004, this was the best that the authors had to offer about the suicidality situation for GLBT young adults in American universities. Without doubt, suicidology researchers had been almost completely indifferent or even neglectful of the welfare of GLBT students by not ever producing research that would reveal whether or not GLBT students were - or were not - more at risk for attempting suicide than their heterosexual counterparts... as it was the case for GLBT adolescents in schools. Yet, there were many data sets available - that solicited both sexual orientation and suicidality/depression information - from which this possibility could have been explored. For example, from 2000 to 2008, the American College Health Association produced 18 data sets (2 per year) known as the National College Health Assessment surveys (ACHA-NCHA), but only the 2000 Spring Survey was reported on in 2005 (Leino & Kisch, 2005; Kisch et al., 2005) with associated GLBT information. However, nothing was reported about GLBT students being at risk for attempting suicide, even if only a trend existed given the possible low counts, by maybe a "risk" factor of "6" as one NYU report notes for the 2003 Spring Survey. Nonetheless, not being heterosexual was the second largest independent predictor (OR = 2.6) for university students having seriously considered suicide in the past year (1999-2000). Interestingly, many NCHA data sets have the counts required to do a GLBT "Attempted Suicide in the Past Year" analysis but all ACHA-NCHA Survey data reports do not mention possible "at risk" GLBT status so that, for example, if they are "at risk," initiatives to help GLB students could be implemented. Massachusetts, for example, does report the GLB "at risk" status when reporting the results of Youth Risk Behavior Surveys (2007: 4.4 times the risk for having attempted suicide in the past year). The same was done in Rhode Island (2007: GLBU students, 4.4 times the risk for having attempted suicide in the past year) and in Washington DC (2007: GLB students, 3.8 times the risk for having attempted suicide in the past year). Others have made the results available for others to disseminate and make public as it was done in Chicago (2005, GLB students, 3-4 times the risk for having attempted suicide in the past year) and in Vermont (2007: GLB students, 7 times the risk for having attempted suicide in the past year, with the results for 2005 also given: GLBQ students, 5 times the risk for having attempted suicide in the past year). In 2007, from another survey carried out at two universities in 2005 (Survey of College Mental Health and Well Being), Whitlock & Knox (2007) reported GLB students to be 4 times more at risk for a lifetime suicide attempt. Gay/lesbian, bisexual and questioning students also had, separately and as a group, the highest associations between lifetime self-injury and suicidality. The small-scale university classroom survey of males by Savin-Williams (2001) reported that about 50% of males were non-heterosexual, that 83% of males (5/6) reporting a true suicide attempt were non-heterosexual, and that the 3 males for whom medical care was associated with the suicide attempt were also non-heterosexual. The Murphy (2007) dissertation study highlighted the possibility that, in American universities, a high risk group for current suicidality - usually ignored by researchers - identify as "heterosexual" but also report some same-sex attraction or sexual behavior. All who report GLBT results from the ACHA-NCHA-like surveys - that solicits only "identity" sexual orientation information - should caveat their results accordingly. In the Murphy (2007) study, 50% (5/10) of the females who had attempted suicide in the past year were non-heterosexual and the two male suicide attempters were non-heterosexual.
"The majority of literature reviews on LGB suicide attempts conclude that LGB youth have a significantly higher rate of attempting suicide than heterosexual youth. Furthermore, most suicide attempts among LGB people occur during adolescence and young adulthood (Kulkin, Chauvin, & Percle, 2000; Proctor & Groze, 1994; Remafedi et al., 1991). (The same holds true for people of all sexual orientations; national hospital data show self-harm rates are highest for youth age 15 through 19 years old (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2007))."Alert! It is sometimes believed that, compared to heterosexual individuals, sexual minority individuals are only more at risk for attempting suicide only during adolescence. However, a New Zealand birth cohort study reports that their "higher risk" for attempting suicide continues to exist between the ages of 21 to 26 years, at least for sexual minority males (Skegg et al., 2003), with a re-analysis by Fergusson et al. (2005) indicating that the higher risk applies for both sexual minority males and females. In the United States, for young adults ranging in age from 18 to 26 years in the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, Silenzio et al. (2007) reports that sexual minority males and females have remained more at risk for having attempted suicide in the past year, compared to their heterosexual counterpart (includes those reporting to be predominantly heterosexual): OR = 1.4<3.0<6.2, controlling for race, gender, and age. During adolescence for the same sample, Russell & Joyner (2001) report the "greater risk" factor to have been - OR = 2.48 (1.7, 3.6) - for sexual minority females, with an OR = 2.45 (1.5, 3.9) for sexual minority males, controlling for demographic factors.
| "Attempted Suicide" Results: Published Studies 1970-1983 Homosexually Oriented Males and Females |
||||
| Study |
Sample GLB (n) |
Compa- rison Group (n) |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N), Odd Ratio (95% CI) |
p |
| Saghir et al., 1970a (F*) Adults: Homophile Organization Chicago & San Francisco |
57 Homo- Sexual |
43 Hetero- Sexual |
23% (13 / 57) vs. 5% (2 / 43) |
0.012 |
| Saghir et al., 1970b (M*) Adults: Homophile Organization Chicago & San Francisco |
85 Homo- Sexual |
35 Hetero- Sexual |
7% (6 / 85) vs. 0% (0 / 35) Note: 5 / 6 attempted before age of 20 years |
0.107 |
| Roesler & Deisher, 1972 (M) - Age = 16-22 Years: Clinical: 48% = previous psychiatric care |
60 Gay / Bisexual |
None | 31% |
-- |
| Bell & Weinberg, 1978 (M, F) Stratified Sampling: 1969, Bay Area, San Francisco Predominantly Homosexual & Predominantly Heterosexual Mean Ages = 26 to 36 Years Complete Tabulated Results |
575 (M) |
284 (M) |
White Males, Lifetime 18.3% (105 / 575 vs. 3.2% (9 / 284) OR = 6.8 (3.4, 13.7) |
0.000 |
| 111 (M) |
53 (M) |
Black Males; Lifetime 19.8% (22 / 111) vs. 1.9% (1 / 53) OR = 12.8 (1.7, 98.2) |
0.002 |
|
| 229 (F) |
101 (F) |
White Females, Lifetime 25.3% (58 / 229) vs. 9.9% (10 / 101) OR = 3.1 (1.5, 6.3) |
0.001 |
|
| 64 (F) |
38 (F) |
Black Females, Lifetime 17.2% (11 / 64) vs. 18.4% (7 / 38) |
0.874 | |
| 575 (M) |
284 (m) |
White Males: To Age 20 Years - 9.4% (54 / 575) vs. 0.7% (2 / 284) OR = 14.6 (3.5, 60.4) |
0.000 |
|
| Jay & Young, 1979 (M, F) Survey Questionnaire National USA |
+5,000 Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual |
None |
40% (M). 39% (F) Attempters + those who only seriously considered suicide. |
-- |
| Harry, 1983a, Using Bell & Weinberg, 1978. Sample Data (1969) |
Analysis of those who seriously considered suicide or attempted suicide (combined) as related to gender non- conformity (high/low rating, to age 17), sexual orientation, and loner status (high/low rating). |
|||
| * F = Female, M = Male |
||||
| "Attempted Suicide" Results: Published Studies 1987-1991 Homosexually Oriented Males and Females |
||||
| Study |
Sample GLB (n) |
Compa- rison Group (n) |
Attempted Suicide Incidences % (n / N) |
p |
| Remafedi, 1987 (M*) Age = 15-19 |
29 |
None |
34% |
-- |
| Bradford & Ryan, 1988, 1994. (F*) Adults: 1984-85 National Volunteer Sample |
1925 |
None |
All: 19%, White: 16% Latina: 28% Black: 27% |
-- |
| Martin & Hetrick, 1988. (M, F) Youth Receiving Social Services New York |
None |
21% |
-- |
|
| Uribe & Harbeck, 1992. (M) Gay High School Students (LA) |
37 |
None |
50% |
-- |
| Uribe & Harbeck, 1992. (F) Lesbian High School Students (LA) |
13 |
None |
23% |
-- |
| Schneider et al., 1989. (M) College & Community Gay Rap Groups (LA) |
106 |
None |
23% |
-- |
| Remafedi et al., 1991. Age = 14-21 Years: Volunteers: Gay Community. US Midwest & Pacific Northwest. - Additional Results. |
139 |
None |
30% 58% of attempts = moderate to low chance of rescuability. |
-- |
| * F = Female, M = Male |
||||
|
Gay And Bisexual Male Youth: Age 14 - 21 Years Remafedi, Farrow & Deisher (1991) |
|||
|
Categories |
|
Undifferentiated: 26% |
|
|
in Category |
(31/137) |
(42/137) / (35/137) |
(28/137) |
|
Percent Incidence |
(15/31) |
(23/77 = 30% ) 1 |
(3/28) 2, 3 |
|
Percent Incidence |
(38/108 = 35.2% ) |
(3/28) 4 |
|
| Bem Sex Role Inventory:
Feminine: High F, Low M scores- Masculine: Low F, High M scores
Androgynous High F & M scores - Undifferentiated: Low F & M scores Greater risk (95%
Confidence Intervals) for attempting suicide: 1. "Feminine" Category
vs. this Category - RR = .98<1.6<2.7 (χ2
= 3.3, p = .068); 2. "Feminine" Category vs. this Category - RR = 1.4<4.5<14.0
(χ2
= 9.8, p = .002); "Androgynous / Undifferentiated" Category vs. this Category
- RR = .91<2.8<8.6 (χ2
= 4.0, p = .044); 4. "Feminine / Androgynous / Undifferentiated" Category
vs. this Category - RR = 1.1<3.3<9.9 (χ2
= 6.3, p = .012). |
|||
| North American Lifetime "Attempted Suicide" Incidences Non-Random: GLB Community or GLB Services Homosexually Oriented Youth: 1993 - 1999 |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age |
| Hammelman (1993) |
48 28 (M*) 20 (F*) |
None |
29% (14 / 48) |
Iowa, USA: GLB Support Groups College / Community: 96% White Age = 15 - 32 Years |
| D'Augelli & Hershberger (1993) |
194 142 (M) 52 (F) |
None |
42% |
GLB Community Support Groups, USA - Canada Age: <= 21 Years |
| Proctor & Groze (1994) |
221 159 (M) 62 (F) |
None |
40.3% (89 / 221) |
GLB Community Groups USA, Canada Age <= 21 Years |
| Remafedi (1994) |
239 (M) |
None |
29.5% (70 / 237) |
GLB Community Sites, Appeals, Advertisements, Referrals. USA Age = 13 - 21 Years |
| Rotheram- Borus et al. (1994) |
132 (M) |
None |
39% (51 / 131) |
Hispanic: 51%, Black: 30%. White: 12%. Hetrick & Martin, New York GLB Service Organization: 1988-91 Age = 14 - 19 Years |
| Waldo et al. (1998) |
54 38 (M) 16 (F) |
None |
31.5% (17 / 54) |
US Rural University Setting Organizations / Events Age = 16 - 21 Years |
| Lehmann et al. (1998) |
53 (F) |
None |
27% |
Study Participants Contacted by Lesbian Organization: USA Age = 15 - 44 Years |
| Grossman & Kerner (1998) |
58 (M) |
None |
26% (15 / 58) |
Volunteers, 1995: New York Drop-In: Hetrick-Martin Institute. Mostly Black and Latino/a Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual Identified Mean Age: 17.6 Years, 14 - 21 Years |
| 32 (F) |
None |
38% (12 / 38) |
||
| Safren & Heimberg (1999) |
56 29 (M) 27 (F) |
48 21 (M) 27 (F) |
30.9% (17 / 55) vs.12.5% (6 / 48) |
USA: After-School Education or Recreation; Job Training, YMCA Age = 16 - 21 Years, About 36% White All Attempters: OR = 3.1 (1.1, 8.8) Attempters With Intent to Die OR = 5.1 (1.1, 24.6) |
| 17.9% (10 / 55) vs. 4.2% (2 / 48) |
||||
| * M = Males - F = Females | ||||
| North American Lifetime "Attempted Suicide" Incidences Non-Random: GLB Community or GLB Services Homosexually Oriented Youth: 2000 - 2008 |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age, Odd Ratio ((5%CI) - p |
| D'Augelli et al. (2001) |
350 (MF*) |
None |
34% Lifetime |
GLB Community Support Groups, USA - Canada Age: <= 21 Years |
| Savin- Williams (2001) |
83 (F) |
None |
17% (14 / 83) |
41% Lesbian: True Attempters See Table |
| 73 (F) 1 to 100% Homosexual |
79 (F) 100% Heterosexual |
10% (7 / 73) vs. 8% (6 / 79) |
University Students: See Table OR: 1.3 (0.41, 5.0), p = 0.661 |
|
| 52 (M) 1 to 100% Homosexual |
61 (M) 100% Heterosexual |
9%: (5 / 53) vs. 2% (1 / 61) |
University Students: See Table 6.2 (0.71, 6.9), p = 0.063 |
|
| D'Augelli (2002) |
542 336 (M) 206 (F) |
None |
37% 36% (M) 39% (F) Lifetime |
D'Augelli & Hershberger (1993) D'Augelli et al. (2001) Combined - 75% White Age = 15 - 21 Years |
| Remafedi (2002) |
254 (M) |
None |
33.5% (85 / 254) (4.7% in the Past Year) |
Volunteers:
Popular Gay Venues in Major metropolitan area: Minneapolis/St. Paul,
Minnesota. Criteria: Same-Sex Sex, Past Year. 85% White, 8.8% Black Age: 15 - 25 Years |
| Carragher & Rivers (2002) |
203 (M) | None |
18.7% (38 / 203) Lifetime |
American Volunteers: Gay Community Mean Age: 25.3 Years, 18 to 30 Years 97% With Some University Education (13%), in College (13%), or with One or More University Degree (71%) Carragher (1999) |
| Rosario et al. (2005) |
156 (MF) 80 (M) 76 (F) |
None |
All: 35.3% (55 / 156) 17.9% (28 / 156) Med. Care |
Volunteers: 3 GLB Community & 2 GLB Student organizations: New York, 1993-95 Latino: 37%, Black: 35%, White: 22% Mean Age: 18.3 (SD: 1.6), 14-21 Years |
| D'Augelli et al. (2005) See Tabulated Results |
361 202 (M) 159 (F) |
None |
31.4% (166 / 528) True Attempts: 14.8% (78 / 528) |
Black (41%), Hispanic (29%), White (27%), New York GLB Service Organizations Age = 15 - 19 Years |
| Clatts et. al. (2005) Additional Results: - Race - - Sexual Orientation - - Suicidality - |
549 |
None | 33.4% Lifetime |
Sampling: Popular Gay Venues, New York 26.7% White: See Tabulated Information Mean Age: 21.7 (SD: 2.9), 17 to 28 Years |
| 320 |
None | 26.6% |
Never Homeless |
|
| 249 |
None | 42.2% | Ever Homeless |
|
| 166 |
None | 41.8% |
Previously Homeless |
|
| 83 |
None |
43.4% |
Presently Homeless |
|
| Walls et al. (2008) |
142 (MF) |
None |
57 / 142 40.1% Lifetime |
GLBT Youth Receiving Services at a Denver, Colorado GLBT Community Social Services Agency: "Rainbow Alley." Age Range: 14-21 Years, 82%: 16-19 Years. 29% White, 28% Bi/Multi-Racial, 20% Latino. |
| Moon et al. (2007) |
77: Only Same-Sex Partners |
None |
21 / 77 27.3% Lifetime |
Volunteers (1999 & 2001): Receiving services at the Richmond Organization for Sexual Minority Youth, Richmond, Virginia. Age Range: 14 to 21 Years Sexually Bisexual Youth are more at risk for attempting suicide, compared to Sexually Homosexual Youth: OR: 1.2<4.4<15.8 |
| 27 Both-Sex Partners |
None |
17 / 26 65.4% Lifetime |
||
| Kipke et al. (2007) |
526 (M) |
None |
All: 4% White: 4% Black: 5% Latino: 4% |
2005
Volunteer Venue Sample, Los Angeles, Age: 18 to 24 years. 95 (37%)
Caucasian, 126 (24%) African American, and 205 (39%) Latino YMSM of
Mexican descent. 74% Gay, 16% Bisexual. Attempted Suicide: Past year Speculated to not be "at risk" by comparing results with author generated national results for 18 year-old males in school: The CDC's Youth Risk Behavior Survey Data Set. See Contested Conclusion in Table Below. |
| 526 (M) |
None |
All: 2% White: 1% Black: 2% Latino: 3% |
||
| * M = Males - F = Females | ||||
| The Savin-Williams 2001 Study 1: Sexual Minority Women "Attempting Suicide" Criteria * |
|||
| Categories |
University Students n = 72 |
Community Support Groups n = 11 |
All N = 83 |
| % White |
90%: 65 / 72 ** |
64%: 7 / 11 |
86.7%: 72 / 83 |
| % Lesbian Identified |
35%: 23 / 72 |
82%: 8 / 11 |
41%: 31 / 83 |
| % Reporting Attempt(s) |
19%: 14 / 72 |
45%: 5 / 11 | 23%: 19 / 83 |
| % True Suicide Attempters |
12%: 9 / 72 |
45%: 5 / 11 | 17%: 14 / 83 |
| % False Suicide Attempters |
7%: 5 / 72 |
0.0%: 0 / 11 | 6%: 5 / 83 |
| % of Suicide Attempters = False |
38% : 5 / 14 |
0.0%: 0 / 5 | 26%: 5 / 19 |
| Sample: USA Volunteers with nonheterosexual sexual identity, Mean Age: 21.9 Years, 18 to 25 Years. *Criteria for Determining False Suicide Attempters: If their "Suicide Attempt(s) was described as one of the following: 1. Thought seriously about it. - 2. Had a plan but did not carry it out. - 3. Had a method but did not carry it out. ** Counts not given. Estimated from given percentages. | |||
| The Savin-Williams 2001 Study 2 Sexual Minority Female University Students "Attempting Suicide" Criteria * |
|||
| Categories |
Kinsey Rating 1 "1 to 7" n = 73 |
Kinsey Rating 1 "0" n = 79 |
Odd Ratios 2 (95%CI), p |
| % Reporting Attempt(s) |
22%: 16 / 73 3 | 11%: 9 / 79 |
2.2 (0.90, 5.3) p = 0.080 |
| % True Suicide Attempters |
10%: 7 / 73 |
8%: 6 / 79 |
1.3 (0.41, 5.0) p = 0.661 |
| % Suicide Attempters Medical Care Received |
3%: 2 / 73 |
3%: 2 / 79 |
1.1 (0.15, 8.0) p = 0.926 |
| % False Suicide Attempters |
12%: 9 / 73 |
4%: 3 / 79 |
3.6 (0.94, 13.9) p = 0.048 |
| % of Suicide Attempters = False |
56% : 9 / 16 |
33%: 3 / 9 |
2.6 (0.47, 14.1) p = 0.271 |
Sample: USA Volunteers Taking Introductory University Courses (Human Development, Sexuality), Mean Age: 20.2 Years, 17 to 25 Years.*Criteria for Determining False Suicide Attempters: If their "Suicide Attempt(s) was described as one of the following: |
|||
| The Savin-Williams 2001 Study 2 Sexual Minority Male University Students "Attempting Suicide" Criteria * |
|||
| Categories |
Kinsey Rating 1 "1 to 7" n = 53 |
Kinsey Rating 1 "0" n = 61 |
Odd Ratios 2 (95%CI), p |
| % Reporting Attempt(s) |
23%: 12 / 53 3 |
2%: 1 / 61 |
17.6 (2.2, 140.3) p = 0.0004 |
| % True Suicide Attempters |
9%: 5 / 53 |
2%: 1 / 61 |
6.2 (0.71, 6.9) p = 0.063 |
| % Suicide Attempters Medical Care Received |
6%: 3 / 53 |
0.0%: 0 / 61 |
p = 0.060 |
| % False Suicide Attempters |
13%: 7 / 53 |
0.0%: 0 / 61 |
p = 0.003 |
| % of Suicide Attempters = False |
58% : 7 / 12 |
0.0%: 0 / 1 |
p = 0.261 |
Sample: USA Volunteers Taking Introductory University Courses (Human Development, Sexuality), Mean Age: 20.2 Years, 17 to 25 Years.*Criteria for Determining False Suicide Attempters: If their "Suicide Attempt(s) was described as one of the following:Note: Given that 5 of the 6 true suicide attempters were non-heterosexual and that the 3 suicide attempters who received medical attention were all non-heterosexual males, this result should maybe have caused a major alert to be sounded at the counseling services of the university where the study sample was taken. |
|||
| Suicidality of 2005 Venue Sampled Gay/Bisexual in Kipke et al. (2007) Study Comparison Issues/Problems With CDC's 2005 National Youth Risk Behavior Survey Results |
||
| Categories |
% Incidence Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
% Incidence, Attempted Suicide, Received Medical Attention, Past Year |
| Kipke et al. (2007) Results: Using YRBS Style Questions For 18 to 24-Year-Old Males |
20 / 526 = 3.8% Given as 4% 1 |
10 / 526 = 1.9% Given as 2% 1 |
| Kipke et al. Generated National YRBS Results, 2005: 18 Year-Old Part of Sample: N = 1046 |
56 / 1046 = 5.35 Given as 6% 2 |
16 / 1046 = 1.53% Given as 2% 2 |
| Note:
As stated by authors, it looks like GB males are not at greater risk
for suicidality, or they are at lesser risk, thus warranting further
investigation. The CDC does not generate and report YRBS results based
on age, but only based on high school grade level. On average, the
oldest male students - those closest in age to the males in the Kipke
et al. (2007) sample - would be in Grade 12. |
||
| CDC (2006) Results, 2005 YRBS, Males, Grade 9 |
6.8% |
2.1% |
| CDC (2006) Results, 2005 YRBS, Males, Grade 10 |
7.3% |
2.2% |
| CDC (2006) Results, 2005 YRBS, Males, Grade 11 | 4.5% |
1.4% |
| CDC (2006) Results, 2005 YRBS, Males, Grade 12 | 4.3% |
1.0% |
| CDC (2006) Results, 2005 YRBS, Males, Grades 9-12 | 6.0% |
1.8% |
| Note:
It appears like GB males, compared to Grade 12 males nationally,
may have twice the risk of an attempted suicide associated with having
received medical attention. Also: Why is the generated national
"attempted suicide" incidence for 18-year-old males by Kipke et al (2007)
almost as high as it is for males in grades 9 and 10? And almost 50%
higher than that generated by the CDC for males in grades 11 and 12 in
2005? |
||
| Note:
The CDC Grades 9-12 national male "attempted suicide" incidences are
obtained from widely varying results ranging from a high incidence of
12.7% in North Carolina, to a low of 2.8% in New Hampshire, and from a
high of 14.2% in a city such as New Orleans to a low of 2.1% in Los
Angeles, where the Kipke sample was taken. Thus explaining why
researchers should always compare their results with those of a similar
sample taken at least in the same city and also in the same year
(becauses changes often occur from year to year) with a similar survey
instrument! Or else, what will be concluded in terms of relative risk
will likely be meaningless, at best; or it may be manipulative, as in
maybe also being 'politically' motivated, at its worse. |
||
| CDC (2006) Results, 2005 YRBS, Males, Grade 9-12, Los Angeles |
2.1% |
1.2% |
| Not
Available, But 'Roughy' Estimated for Grades 11-12 Males in the Los
Angeles 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. This was done using, as a
guide, the relative incidences in the above national "attempted suicide" incidences for males. |
2.1% X (4.3 / 6.0 = 0.73) 1.5% |
1.2% X (1.25 / 1.8% = 0.69) 0.83 |
| Note:
As a rule, the two "attempted suicide" incidences for males decrease
significantly from Grades 9-10 to Grades 11-12, and the incidences
likely continue to decrease to let's say the mean age of 20 (being
another 3 years older, on average), or for males ranging in age from 18
to 24 years, as in the Kipke et al. sample. Therefore, for males aged
18 to 24 years living in Los Angeles in 2005, the "attempted suicide"
incidences may have been yet another third less than for the above
estimate for Grades 11-12 males in LA. |
||
| Estimated Incidences of 18-24-year-old males in LA in 2005. These figures also include the likely overrepresented suicidality of gay/bisexual males in the sample studied. Therefore, the incidences would be even lower for heterosexual males only. |
1.0% |
0.56% |
| Meaning? Possible? Likely? 3 If so, similar to Silenzio et al (2007) results given in Table for young adults aged 18 to 26 years. Also similar to Whitlock & Knox (2007) result for mostly undergraduate students at two universities: Table. |
Kipke et al. GB Males: 4-Times More at Risk. |
Kipke et al. GB Males: Almost 4-Times The Risk |
1. Possible Non-Responders to the Question. |
||
| Men Who Have Sex With Men (MSM): New York Age: 17 to 28 Years - Mean: 21.7 Years: 'Race'/Ethnicity |
|||||
| Categories |
All MSM Males ** |
** Ever Homeless |
Never Homeless |
Previously Homeless |
Currently Homeless |
| N's Percent |
569 100% |
249 43.8% |
320 56.2% |
166 29.2% |
83 14.7% |
| Age: Mean, (SD) |
21.7 (2.9) |
21.8 (2.9) | 21.6 (2.9) |
21.4 (2.9) |
|
| White, % Category, % White, n's* |
26.7% 100% 152 |
16.5% 27.0% 41 : 111 |
34.7% 73.0% 111 : 41 |
20.5% 22.4% 34 : 118 |
8.4% 4.6% 7 : 145 |
| Black, % of Category, % Black, n's* OR (95%CI): vs. White p *** |
22.7% 100% 129 |
24.1% 46.5% 60 : 69 2.4 (1.4, 3.9) 0.0006 |
21.6% 53.5% 69 : 60 |
22.9% 29.4% 38 : 91 1.4 (0.85, 2.5) 0.175 |
26.5% 17.1% 22 : 107 4.3 (1.7, 10.3) 0.0006 |
| Hispanic, % of Category, % Hispanic, n's* OR (95%CI): vs. White p *** |
40.4% 100% 230 |
50.2% 54.3% 125 : 105 3.2 (2.1, 5.0) 0.0000 |
32.8% 45.7% 105 : 125 |
48.8% 35.2% 81 : 149 1.9 (1.2, 3.0) 0.007 |
53.0% 19.1% 44 : 186 4.9 (2.1, 11.2) 0.0000 |
| Others, % of Category, % Others, n's* OR (95%CI): vs. White p *** |
10.2% 100% 58 |
9.2% 39.6% 23 : 35 1.8 (0.94, 3.4) 0.074 |
10.9% 60.4% 35 : 23 |
7.8% 22.4% 13 : 45 1.0 (0.48, 2.1) 0.994 |
12.0% 17.2% 10 : 48 4.3 (1.6, 12.0) 0.003 |
| *** Statistics 4 'Races': Chi Square |
28.7 0.001 |
28.7 0.000 |
8.8 0.05 |
16.9 0.001 |
|
| Data Source: Clatts et. al. (2005) * The n's are not given. Estimated from given percentages in Homeless Categories n's = Yes : No - within each 'Race'/Ethnic category Assuming that all study participants responded to the questions asked. ** Generally not given. Calculated from other data. *** Odd Ratios and Significance calculated by web page author. |
|||||
| Men Who Have Sex With Men (MSM): New York Sexual Orientation Categories |
|||||
| Categories |
All MSM Males ** |
** Ever Homeless |
Never Homeless |
Previously Homeless |
Currently Homeless |
| N's Percent |
569 100% |
249 43.8% |
320 56.2% |
166 29.2% |
83 14.7% |
| Age: Mean, (SD) |
21.7 (2.9) |
21.8 (2.9) | 21.6 (2.9) |
21.4 (2.9) |
|
| Gay, % of Category % of Gay Males n's* |
63.4% 100% 361 |
49.4% 34.1% 123 : 238 |
74.4% 65.9% 238 : 123 |
56.0% 25.8% 93 : 268 |
36.1% 8.3% 30 : 331 |
| Bisexual, % of Category % of Bisexual Males n's* OR (95%CI): vs. Gay p *** |
23.9% 100% 136 |
31.3% 57.4% 78 : 58 2.6 (1.7, 3.9) 0.0000 |
17.8% 42.6% 58 : 78 |
29.5% 36.0% 49 : 87 1.6 (1.1, 2.5) 0.024 |
34.9% 21.3% 29 : 107 3.0 (1.7, 5.2) 0.0000 |
| Hetero..., % of Category % of Heterosexual Males n's* OR (95%CI): vs. Gay p *** |
7.2% 100% 41 |
12.0% 73.2% 30 : 11 5.3 (2.6, 10.9) 0.000 |
3.4% 28.8% 11 : 30 |
7.2% 29.3% 12 : 29 1.2 (0.58, 2.4) 0.628 |
21.7% 43.9% 18 : 23 8.6 (4,2, 17.8) 0.0000 |
| Other, % of Category, % of "Other" Males, n's* OR (95%CI): vs. Gay p *** |
5.6% 100% 32 |
7.2% 56.3% 18 : 14 2.5 (1.2, 5.2) 0.012 |
4.4% 43.8% 14 : 18 |
7.2% 37.5% 12 : 20 1.7 (0.81, 3.7) 0.150 |
7.2% 18.8% 6 : 26 2.5 (0.97, 6.7) 0.0497 |
| Total |
100% 570 |
100% 249 |
100% 321 |
99.9% 166 |
99.9% 83 |
| *** Statistics 4 Sex Orientations Chi Square |
40.4 0.001 |
40.4 0.001 |
6.2 0.20 |
45.2 0.001 |
|
| Trans..., % of Category % of Transgender Males n's* OR (95%CI): vs. Gay p *** |
8.8% 100% 50 |
11.6% 58.0% 29 : 21 2.7 (1.5, 4.9) 0.001 |
6.6% 42.0% 21 : 29 |
7.8% 26.0% 13 : 37 1.0 (0.52, 2.0) 0.971 |
19.3% 32.0% 16 : 36 4.9 (2.4, 9.8) 0.0000 |
| Data Source: Clatts et. al. (2005) * The n's are not given. Estimated from given percentages in Homeless Categories n's = Yes : No - within each Sexual Orientation category Assuming that all study participants responded to the questions asked. ** Generally not given. Calculated from other data. *** Odd Ratios and Significance calculated by web page author. Transgender compared to Gay, but some transgender identified MSMs may also have identified as gay. |
|||||
| Men Who Have Sex With Men (MSM): New York Age: 17 to 28 Years - Mean: 21.7 Years: 'Race'/Ethnicity |
|||||
| Categories |
All MSM Males ** |
** Ever Homeless |
Never Homeless |
Previously Homeless |
Currently Homeless |
| N's Percent |
569 100% |
249 43.8% |
320 56.2% |
166 29.2% |
83 14.7% |
| Age: Mean, (SD) |
21.7 (2.9) |
21.8 (2.9) | 21.6 (2.9) |
21.4 (2.9) |
|
| Attempted Suicide: % % of Suicide Attempters * n's: Attempters : Non-Att OR: vs. Never Homeless p *** |
33.4% 100% 190 : 379 |
42.2% 55.3% 105 : 144 2.0 (1.4, 2.9) 0.0000 |
26.6% 44.7% 85 : 235 |
41.8% 36.3% 69 : 97 2.0 (1.3, 2.9) 0.0007 |
43.4% 19.9% 36 : 47 2.1 (1.3, 3.5) 0.0029 |
| % Attempters = Multiple Attempters |
46.8% ** |
54.3% ** |
37.6% |
53.6% |
55.6% |
| Multiple S. Attempters: % % of Multiple Attempters * n's OR: vs. Never Homeless p *** |
15.6% 100% 89 : 480 |
22.9% 64.0% 57 : 192 2.7 (1.7, 4.3) 0.0000 |
10.0% 36.0% 32 : 288 |
22.4% 41.6% 37 : 129 2.6 (1.5, 4.3) 0.0002 |
24.1% 22.5% 20 : 63 2.9 (1.5, 5.3) 0.0006 |
| % Attempters = Attempted, Sex Orientation (S.O.) Reason |
34.7% ** |
33.3% ** |
36.2% |
32.4% |
36.4% |
| S.O. Suicide Attempters: % % of S.O. Attempters * n's OR: vs. Never Homeless p *** |
11.6% 100% 66 : 503 |
14.1% 53.0% 35 : 214 1.5 (0.91, 2.6) 0.106 |
9.6% 47.0% 31 : 289 |
13.5% 33.3% 22 : 144 1.4 (0.80, 2.5) 0.232 |
15.8% 19..7% 13 : 70 1.7 (0.86, 3.5) 0.120 |
| Data Source: Clatts et. al. (2005) * The n's are not given. Estimated from given percentages in Homeless Categories n's = Yes : No - within Attempted Suicide category Assuming that all study participants responded to the questions asked. ** Generally not given. Calculated from other data. *** Odd Ratios and Significance calculated by web page author. |
|||||
| The D'Augelli et al. 2005 Study of New York GLB Youth "Attempting Suicide" Criteria |
|||
| All Reporting Having Attempting Suicide |
Suicide Attempters |
n's |
Category Described Attempt: Serious / Not Serious Intent To Die |
| All Youths Reporting to Have Attempted Suicide: 166 / 528 (31.4%) Those Deemed to Have Attempted Suicide: 78 / 528 (14.8%) Those Deemed to Have Attempted Suicide in Final Study Sample (Data Complete): 61 / 361 (16.9%) |
Removed As Suicide Attempters * |
28 |
Report or Indication of Having Attempted Suicide |
| 60 Removed As Suicide Attempters |
30 |
Not Serious, No Intent to Die |
|
| 23 |
Serious, No Intent to Die |
||
| 7 |
No Information Given |
||
| 78 Deemed To Be Real Suicide Attempters |
21 |
Not Serious, Intent to Die |
|
| 25 |
Serious, Intent to Die |
||
| 22 |
Very Serious, Intent to Die, with 7 Having No Intent to Die |
||
| * 19 were removed because "attempting suicide" was reported in questionnaire, but not in interview. 9 were removed because "attempting suicide" was only threatened, but not done |
|||
| American Lifetime "Attempted Suicide" Incidences Non-Random: GLB Community, GLB Services Homosexually Oriented Adults: 1994 - 2009 |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odd Ratios (95%CI) |
| Ryan et al. (2009) |
114 (M) 110 (F) 107 White 117 Latino |
None |
Range For Groups: 27.3-54.8%, Lifetime All: 40.6% |
Volunteer
Sample from 249 GLB Venues, San Francisco. Age Range: 21-25 Years, Mean
age: 22.8 Years. Sample Criteria: GLB Self-Identified and having come
out to at least one parent/guardian in adolescence. Additional Results: Table Below, including Family Rejection effects. |
| Meyer et al. (2008) |
193 (M) 195 (F) 388 (MF) 132 - White 128 - Black 128 - Latino |
None |
8.4%, Lifetime Serious Suicide Attempt 68.8%, One or More Mental Disorder, Lifetime |
Volunteers, 2004-05 Venue Sampling, New York City Information to determine "serious suicide attempts" was obtained via the computer- assisted personal interview (Version 19) of the WHO World Mental Health Survey: the Composite International Diagnostic Interview. See Table Below for Variable Results. |
| Walter et al. (2008) |
244 (M*) |
None |
59 / 241 24.5% Lifetime |
*244 mostly male sexual minority American Indians from a volunteer multi-city sample (includes 10 female-to-male transsexual individuals) |
| Koh & Ross (2006) |
524 (F) Lesbian |
637 (F) Hetero- sexual |
16.7% (85 / 510) vs. 10.2% (63/617) Lifetine |
USA Volunteers: Inpatients at General Health Care Sites, Lesbian Health Clinics. Mean Ages: 36-41, SDs: 9 to 13 Years 81% to 85% Caucasian. ORs calculated from counts estimated from given data. Lesbian vs. Hetero. : OR = 1.4 (1.006, 2.0) Bisexual vs. Hetero.: OR = 2.4 (1.5, 3.8) |
| 143 (F) Bisexual |
637 (F) Hetero- sexual |
21.3% (30 / 141)vs 10.2% (63/617) Lifetime |
||
| Balsam et al. (2005) Estimates: Additional Results |
264 (M*) |
185 (M) |
11.4% vs 3.3% |
OR = 3.8 (1.6, 9.4) - To Age 17 years |
| 264 (M) |
185 (M) |
10.6% vs. 3.3% |
OR =
3.5 (1.4, 8.7) - Age 18 + Years |
|
| 457 (F) |
358 (F) |
9.8% vs. 6.2% |
OR = 1.6 (0.95, 2.7) - To Age 17 years | |
| 457 (F) |
348 9F) |
8.7% vs. 4.4% |
OR = 2.1 (1.1, 3.8) - Age 18 + Years | |
| Roberts et al. (2004) |
1,139 (F) |
None |
19.5% Lifetime |
Volunteers, Via Outreach: 1997-2000. Sample From 44 American States. Mean Age = 40 Years (Approx) . Age Range = 15-55+ Years For 146 / 225 Suicide Attempters, First Attempt Occurred <= 18 Years |
| Matthews et al. (2002) |
550 (F) Lesbian / Bisexual |
279 (F) Hetero- sexual |
22% (91 / 414) vs. 13% (22 / 169) Lifetime |
Volunteers, Lesbian Communities, in Three Large American Cities: 1994-96. Mean Age: 43 Years Most Suicide Attempts: 15 to 29 Years OR = 1.9 (1.2, 3.1): An Estimate |
| McBee- Strayer & Rogers (2002) |
162 (MF) 85 (M) 75 (F) |
None |
36.4% Lifetime |
USA Volunteers: GLB Organizations & Snowballing. - Mean Age: 37.1. (SD: 12.0), 18 to 64 Years Attempters: 23.4% (Ambivalence) + 13.0% (Intent to Die) = 36.4% |
| D'Augelli & Grossman (2001) Grossman et al. (2001) |
416 295 (M) 121 (F) |
None |
12.5% (52 / 416) Lifetime |
Volunteers Obtained Via Community Organizations: Many American States, and Ontario, Canada: 1997-98. Age = 60 - 91 Years, Mean: 68.5 Years, SD: 5.8 Years Most Attempted Suicide Between ages 22 to 59 years. |
| Morris et al. (2001) |
2,401 (F) Mostly Lesbian/Gay |
None |
21.5%, Lifetime About 52% of them attempted suicide two or more times. On Suicidality Scale: Native Americans More at Risk. |
Volunteers: National Lesbian Wellness Survey Average Age: 36 Years. Range: 15-83 Years. White (75%, N=1,809), African American (10%, N=231), Latina (7%, N=173), Native American (4%, N=85), and Asian American/Pacific Islander, (3%, N=63), with 1% (N=40) indicated "other". 75% with a one or more college degrees. |
| Sorensen & Roberts (1997) |
1,633 (F) |
None |
18% Lifetime |
USA
Volunteers, Via Outreach: 1987. Median Age = 32. Years. Age Range = 16
- 82 Years. 46% of Suicide Attempts Occurred Between Ages or 13 to 18
Years |
| Bradford & Ryan (1988, 1994) |
1,925 (F) |
None |
All: 19%, Lifetime White: 16% Latina: 28% Black: 27% |
National American Volunteer Snowball Sample Taken in 1984-85. Age = 17 - 80 Years 80% Between Ages of 25 - 44 Years |
| * M = Males - F = Females | ||||
| 224 American White and Latino Young Adults, 21 to 25 Years Old GLB Identified & Out to At Least One Parent / Guardian in Adolescence Suicidality and Depression: Effects of Family Rejection 1 |
||||||
| Categories / Variables 4 |
Rejection Scale Score OR 2 |
Rejection Level |
Mode- rate Rejec- tion OR |
High Rejec- tion OR |
||
| Low |
Mode- rate |
High |
||||
| Depression, Current CES-D > 16 |
2.21 (1.62–3.01) |
22.4% |
44.6% |
63.5% | 2.92 (1.42–6.00) |
5.94 (2.86–12.34) |
| Suicide Ideation, Past 6 Months |
2.13 (1.53–2.95 |
11.8% |
21.6% |
43.2% | 2.12 (0.86–5.18) |
5.64 (2.42–13.14) |
| Attempted Suicide, Ever |
3.09 (2.18–4.37) |
19.7% |
35.1% |
67.6% | 2.29 (1.08–4.83) |
8.35 (3.90–17.85) |
| Categories / Variables 4 |
All |
Males |
Females |
Effects Statistically Significant |
||
| White |
Latino |
White |
Latino |
|||
| N's |
224 |
52 |
62 |
55 |
55 |
- |
| Mean Age, Years At Survey Time |
22.8 |
22.9 |
22.9 |
23.1 |
22.6 |
None |
| Come Out, Parent(s) Mean Age, Years |
15.8 |
15.2 |
15.8 |
16.2 |
16.1 |
None |
| Depression, Current CES-D > 16 |
43.3% |
44.2% |
58.1% |
41.8% |
27.3% |
GxE 3 |
| Suicide Ideation, Past 6 Months |
25.4% |
25.0% |
35.5% |
27.3% |
12.7% |
GxE 3 |
| Attempted Suicide, Ever |
40.6% |
44.2% |
54.8% |
34.5% |
27.3% |
None |
| 1.
The selection process for this study creates an unknown: What are the
possible effects on GLB self-identified adolescents if, during
adolescence, they did not come out to at least one parent or guardian?
Study by Ryan et al. (2009). 2. All ORs, 95% Confidence Intervals 3. GxE: GxE indicates gender-by-ethnicity interaction, p < 0.05 4. At risk results also given in the paper for subtance abuse and taking sexual risks. |
||||||
| Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual Adults, and Their Siblings "Attempted Suicide" Incidences / Risks Homosexual/Bisexual vs. Heterosexual |
||||
| Sexual Orientation » |
Hetero- sexual |
Bisexual |
Homosexual |
Homosexual & Bisexual * |
| Men |
||||
| Counts in Categories | 185 |
38 |
226 |
264 |
| Attempted Suicide < 18 Years ** Odd Ratios (95%CI) |
3.3% | 17.1% 5.6 (1.7, 18.4) |
10.5% 3.5 (1.4, 8.9) |
11.4% 3.8 (1.6, 9.4) |
| Attempted Suicide 18 + Years ** Odd Ratios (95%CI) |
3.3% |
11.4% 3.4 (0.94, 13.1) |
10.5% 3.5 (1.4, 8.9) |
10.6% 3.5 (1.4, 8.7) |
| Lifetime |
? |
? |
? |
? |
| Women |
||||
| Counts in Categories | 348 |
125 |
332 |
457 |
| Attempted Suicide < 18 Years ** Odd Ratios (95%CI) |
6.2% |
17.4% 3.2 (1.7, 5.9) |
7.0% 1.1 (0.60, 2.0) |
9.8% 1.6 (0.95, 2.7) |
| Attempted Suicide 18 + Years ** Odd Ratios (95%CI) |
4.4% |
10.7% 2.6 (1.2, 5.6) |
7.9% 1.9 (0.98, 3.6) |
8.7% 2.1 (1.1, 3.8) |
| Lifetime | ? |
? |
? |
? |
| Data Source: Balsam et al. (2005) GLB Sampling via Magazine/Web Advertisement. Their Siblings: via mail. Mean Ages For Groups: 31.6-39.3 Years (SDs: 10.3-11.7 Years). 91.7% European American * Data For Combined Homosexual & Bisexual Groups Not Given. Estimated From Given Percentages. ** Odds Ratio Calculated From Estimated Counts, Assuming No Non-Responders to Questions. The actual Odds Ratio Would be a Little Less. |
||||
| Lifetime Serious Suicide Attempts & Mental Disorders White, Black & Latino/a Gay, Lesbian & Bisexual Adults in New York City |
|||||
| Categories * |
Any Anxiety Disorder |
Any Mood Disorder |
Any Substance Use Disorder |
Any Disorder |
Serious Suicide Attempt |
| All, N = 388 |
44.3% |
30.7% |
38.4% |
69.8% |
8.3% |
| Male, n = 193 |
43.0% |
26.4% |
36.8% |
65.3% |
9.3% |
| Female, n = 195 |
45.6% |
34.9% |
40.0% |
74.4% |
7.2% |
| White, n = 132 |
47.0% |
38.6% |
41.7% |
76.5% |
4.6% |
| Black, n = 128 |
36.7% |
21.9% |
30.5% |
60.2% |
7.0% |
| Latino/a, n = 128 |
49.2% |
31.3% |
43.0% |
72.7% |
13.3% |
| Lesbian/Gay, n = 318 |
43.7% |
30.2% |
35.5% |
68.2% |
7.9% |
| Bisexual, n = 70 |
47.1% |
32.9% |
51.4% |
77.1% |
10.0% |
| 18 - 29 Years, n = 172 |
46.5% |
29.1% |
35.5% |
69.8% |
8.7% |
| 30 - 44 Years, n = 171 |
43.9% |
25.7% |
39.8% |
67.8% |
5.9% |
| 45 - 59 Years, n = 45 |
37.8% |
55.6% |
44.4% |
77.8% |
15.6% |
| Data Source: Meyer et al. (2008) - * Lifetime Incidences (Percent: %) for All Categories Information to determine "mental disorders" & "serious suicide attempts" was obtained via the computer- assisted
personal interview (Version 19) of the WHO World Mental Health Survey:
the Composite International Diagnostic Interview.
|
|||||
| Canadian Lifetime "Attempted Suicide" Incidences Non-Random: GLB Community or GLB Services Homosexually Oriented Adults: AIDS/HIV Cohort Studies |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide Incidence |
Sampling Information Age |
| Botnick et al. (2002) |
345 ** MSM |
None |
19.4% (67 / 345) Lifetime |
Vancouver, British Columbia - 1998 Subsample: Vanguard AIDS/HIV Cohort Men (Age = 18 to 30 Years) Identified as Gay / Bisexual, or Having Sex With Men |
| Otis (2000) |
629 msm |
None |
36.1% Lifetime |
Montreal, Canada - 1999 Subsample: Omega AIDS/HIV Cohort Men (Mean Age = 32 Years) Identified as Gay / Bisexual, or Having Sex With Men |
| * M = Males - F = Females - MSM: Men Who Have Sex With Men | ||||
| Lifetime "Self Harm / Attempted Suicide" Incidences Non-Random GLB Study Populations: United Kingdom |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Self Harm / Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Comments |
| Rivers (2000) |
116 (MF*) 92 (M) |
None |
37.1% (43 / 116) Self Harm / Suicide Attempt(s) Lifetime |
Volunteers: Advertising in GLB Community Venues. Follow-up Questionnaire to 190
United Kingdom Participants in a Previous Study. Mean Age = 28 Years, 16 to 54 Years Men: 16 to 54 years, Women: 16 to 44 Years Age Range Information: Rivers (2004) |
| Cant (2002) |
85 (MF) |
None |
32% Attempted Suicide 35% Self-Harm |
The Metro Centre in Greenwich that is accessed by some young lesbian, gay and bisexual people from Lambeth, Southwark and Lewisham. Data collected on 85 youth registered there from October 2001 to April 2002: 85 young people. |
| Carragher & Rivers (2002) |
93 (M) |
None |
33.7% (29 / 86) Self Harm / Suicide Attempt(s) Lifetime |
Male Part of Rivers (2000) UK Sample. Mean Age = 28 Years, SD: 9.0 Years Age Range: 16 to 54 Years |
| Webb & Wright (2001) |
1145 (MF) |
None |
Attempted S. 18.3% (210 / 1145) Lifetime |
90%
Living in Brighton & Hove. Women: significantly more likely than
men to have self-harmed. No significant differences for attempting
suicide. Serious thoughts of suicide, ever: declines from 53.1% to
21.6%, from age group 16-25, to age group 65+ Age = 16 - 65+ |
| Self Harm: 10.6% (121 / 1145) Lifetime |
||||
| Hutchison et al. (2003) |
95 (M) |
None |
Self Harm: 28.4% (27 / 95) Lifetime |
Volunteers: Gay Venues (Edinburgh, Scotland) Age = 15 - 26 Years Self Harm = No Intent To Die 42% of Suicide Attempters: Repeat Attempters Compared to National Male Statistics: Self Harm: 5.6 Times More likely Attempted Suicide: 6.7 Times More Likely |
| Attempted S. 27.4% (26 / 95) Lifetime |
||||
| King et al. (2003)* & Warner et al. (2004)* |
656 (M) Gay |
505 (M) Hetero- sexual |
Self Harm** 25% vs. 13.5% |
Snowball Sampling (England, Wales): Gay / Lesbian Venues, Publications, Advertisements, Followed by Recruitment: Friends, etc. Mean Age = 36.4 Years Self-Harm: Lifetime |
| 84 (M) Bisexual |
505 (M) Hetero- sexual |
Self Harm** 27% vs. 13.5% |
Snowball Sampling (As Above) Mean Age = 35.5 Years |
|
| 430 (F) Lesbian |
588 (F) Hetero- sexual |
Self Harm** 31% vs. 16.5% |
Snowball Sampling (As Above) Mean Age = 34.2 Years |
|
| 111 (F) Bisexual |
588 (F) Hetero- sexual |
Self Harm** 33% vs. 16.5% |
Snowball Sampling (As Above) Mean Age = 29.8 Years |
|
| Cull et al. (2006) |
44 GLBT Homeless Youth |
None |
Attempted Suicide: > 66.7% Lifetime |
Volunteer: GLBT Presently/Past Homeless in Brighton and Hove, England - Age = 16 - 25 Years. 'Nearly all reported a history of mental health problems or substance misuse. Half reported alcohol or substance misuse. Over two thirds had a history of attempting suicide.' |
| Meads et al. (2007) |
449 (F) 93.5% LGB Identified |
None |
31.3% Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
Volunteer: Measure for Measure 1 Study (2002) Commissioned by the West Midlands South Strategic Health Authority |
| 166 (F) 77% LGB Identified |
None |
20.0% Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
Volunteer: Measure for Measure 2 Study (2005) Commissioned by the West Midlands South Strategic Health Authority |
|
| Hunt & Fish (2008) |
5,053 (F) 81% Lesbian Identified |
None |
5.0% Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
England: Volunteer Sample: Online & Pencil/Paper 82% White British. Age Range: 14 to 84 Years. Attempted Suicide Incidence Range, in the Past Year, in 10 Regions: 3.5% to 7.4%. See Table Below. Self-Harm, With No Intention of Killing Self, in the Past Year: Incidence Range: 15.9% to 22.9%, in 10 Regions. See Table Below. Results Similar for Wales: See Table Below. |
| None |
20.0% Self-Harm, Past Year |
|||
| Hunt & Fish (2008a) |
510 (F) 77.8% Lesbian Identified |
None |
4.8% Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
Scotland: Volunteer Sample: Online & Pencil/Paper Age Range: 15 to 72 years. Attempted Suicide Incidence Range, in the Past Year, in 10 Regions: 1.1% to 10.2%. See Table Below. Self-Harm, With No Intention of Killing Self, in the Past Year: Incidence Range: 14.6% to 39.1%, in 10 Regions. See Table Below. |
| None |
20.8% Self-Harm, Past Year |
|||
| ** Described as "Self Harm" in 2003 Paper, but as "Attempted Suicide" in 2004 Paper. * M = Males - F = Females |
||||
| Attempted Suicide & Self-Harm: Lesbian & Bisexual Women in United Kingdom "Prescription For Change" Studies by Hunt & Fish (2008 & 2008a) |
|||||
| Categories / Strategic Health Authority (SHA) |
N's |
% Lesbian * |
% Bisexual Women * |
% Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
% Self-Harm, No Death Intent Past year |
| All England |
5,043 |
80.9% |
15.7% |
5.0% |
20.0% |
| East of England |
415 |
81.2% |
17.6% | 7.4% |
22.2% |
| East Midlands |
377 |
82.5% |
14.9% | 4.2% |
17.3% |
| London |
1,330 |
79.9% |
15.7% | 3.5% |
18.1% |
| North East |
224 |
79.9% |
16.5% | 6.4% |
22.6% |
| North West |
638 |
81.3% |
15.4% | 5.1% |
22.0% |
| South Central |
369 |
78.3% |
17.9% | 4.9% |
23.5% |
| South East Coast |
449 |
81.1% |
15.1% | 5.8% |
19.0% |
| South West |
376 |
82.4% |
14.4% | 5.6% |
22.9% |
| West Midlands |
425 |
81.6% |
15.8% | 5.2% |
15.9% |
| Yorkshire & Humber |
418 |
82.2% |
14.2% | 4.6% |
19.7% |
| England (SHA unknown) |
22 |
86.4% |
13.6% | 31.8% |
45.5% |
| All Wales |
267 |
81.3% |
16.1% | 6.4% |
22.7% |
| South East (Wales) |
135 |
80.7% |
16.3% | 4.5% |
20.3% |
| Mid & West (Wales) |
81 |
80.2% |
17.3% | 11.1% |
24.7% |
| North Wales | 51 |
84.3% |
13.7% | 3.9% |
26.0% |
| Scotland |
510 |
77.8% |
18.2% |
4.8% |
20.6% |
| Greater Glasgow & Clyde |
157 |
81.5% |
15.9% |
5.2% |
14.6% |
| Lothian |
149 |
73.8% |
20.8% |
3.4% |
17.6% |
| Other Areas |
204 |
74.0% to 81.8% |
15.9% to 21.2% |
1.1% to 10.2% |
19.5% to 39.1% |
* Those not Identifying as Lesbian or Bisexual are Classified as "Other". Study Commentary: "One in five lesbian and bisexual women have deliberately harmed themselves in the last year, compared to 0.4 per cent of the general population. Half of women under the age of 20 have self-harmed compared to one in fifteen of teenagers generally. Five per cent have attempted to take their life in the last year and sixteen per cent of women under the age of 20 have attempted to take their life. ChildLine estimatethat 0.12 per cent of people under 18 have attempted suicide." |
|||||
| Lifetime "Self Harm / Attempted Suicide" Incidences Non-Random GLB Study Populations: Ireland |
||||
| Study | Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Self Harm / Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Comments |
| Carolan & Redmond (2003) |
362 232 (M) 130 (F |
None |
Self Harm 26.2% (95 / 362) |
Volunteers: Questionnaire promoted through youth, community and gay organisations, and online. Northern Ireland Age = <= 25 Years Self-Harm / Attempted Suicide: Lifetime |
| Attempted S. 28.7% (104 / 362) |
||||
| McNamee (2006) |
190 (M) 93.4% Gay Bisexual Identified |
None |
27.1% Attempted Suicide 30.7% Self-Harmed |
Volunteers: Northern Ireland Mean Age: 20.6 Years, 15 to 25 Years 60% Live in Belfast or Derry/Londonderry. Self-Harm / Attempted Suicide: Lifetime |
| CCL (2006) |
107 (F) 85% Lesbian Identified |
None |
14.2% Attempted Suicide 23.8% Self-Harmed |
Volunteers: Cork Region, Northern Ireland Age: 8.5% (< 23 years), 45% (23-49 Years), 44% (. 49 Years) Self-Harm / Attempted Suicide: Lifetime |
| Mayock et al. (2009) Internet Sample Age Range: 14-73 years Mean Age: 30.5 Years Ireland Residents: 90%* |
Male n = 707 |
None | 105 / 707 14.8% |
Attempted Suicide in Past 12 months, 6 months, 30 days: 1.6% (n = 11), 1.0% (7), 0.42% (3), respectively |
| Female n = 377 |
None | 89 / 377 23.6% |
Attempted Suicide in Past 12 months, 6 months, 30 days: 3.7% (n = 14), 2.4% (9), 0.79% (3), respectively |
|
| Other n = 22 |
None | 3 / 22 13.6% |
Attempted Suicide in Past 12 months, 6 months, 30 days: 0.0% (n = 0), 0.0% (0), 0.0% (0). respectively |
|
| All n = 1,110 |
None | 197 / 1,110 17.7% |
Attempted Suicide in Past 12 months, 6 months, 30 days: 2.3% (n = 25), 1.4% (16), 0.54 (6), respectively |
|
| Trans- gender n = 46 |
None |
12 / 46 26.1% |
Attempted Suicide in Past 12 months, 6 months, 30 days: 6.5% (n = 3), 6.5% (3), 0.0% (9), respectively |
|
| Interview Sample n = 22 |
None |
13 / 22 59.1% |
Qualitative Part of the Study. For Above Qantitative Study: First suicide attempts were Very Much (12%), Very (35%) and Somewhat (25%) related to LGBT Identification | |
| * Over 90% were residents in the Republic of Ireland. 4% were living in Northern Ireland. |
||||
| Adolescent School Surveys: Random or Near-Random "Attempted Suicide" Risk: Same-Sex Sexual Orientation/Identity vs. Heterosexual Identity Published American Studies |
||||
| Study | Sexual Minority |
Others |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Grade - Age OR, (95% CI) Comments |
| Remafedi et. al (1998) |
178 (M*) Homo/Bi Sexual |
168 (M) Heterosexual Matched |
28.1% vs. 4.2% RR: 6.8 Lifetime |
Adolescent Health Survey Minnesota,1987 N = 36,254. Grades 7 to 12 Sexual Minority / Others = Self-Identification Males: OR = 7.1 (3.1, 16.5) Females: OR - 1.5 (0.81, 2.8) ns |
| 166 (F*) Homo/Bi Sexual |
145 (F) Heterosexual Matched |
20.5% vs. 14.5% RR: 1.4 ns. Lifetime |
||
| Garofalo et. al (1999) |
129 (MF) GLBN |
3,236 (MF) Heterosexual |
31.0% vs. 9.1% RR: 3.4 In The Past 12 Months |
***
YRBS Massachusetts, 1995. N = 3,365 - GLBN: Self-Identified as Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual or 'Not Sure' of Sexual Orientation: OR = 2.28 (1.4,
3.4) With Control Variables |
| ? (M) GLBN |
? (M) Heterosexual |
** 41.6% vs. 6.4% RR: 6.5 12 Months |
OR = 3.74 (1.9, 7.3) With Control Variables Attempted Suicide: Past 12 Months |
|
| ? (F) GLBN |
? (F) Heterosexual |
** 27.1% vs. 13.4% RR: 2.0 Past 12 Months |
OR = 1.42 (0.65, 3.1) ns With Control Variables Attempted Suicide: Past 12 Months |
|
| ? (MF) Same-Sex Sex, Ever |
? (MF) No Same-Sex Sex, Ever |
30.6% vs. 9.2% RR: 3.3 Past 12 Months |
OR: Not Given Attempted Suicide: Past 12 Months |
|
| Bontempo & D'Augelli (2002) |
196 (M) GBUS |
4,416 (M) Heterosexual |
20.4% vs. 1.2% RR: 17.0 Past 12 Month |
1995
Massachusetts & Vermont: YRBSs, Combined: Grade 9 to 12. - Gay,
Lesbian, Bisexual, Unsure Identity and/or Same-Sex Sex Reported: GLBUS. Attempted Suicide 4 or More Times In Past 12 Months Statistical Signicance for RRs: p < 0.001 |
| 119 (F) LBUS |
4,457 (F) Heterosexual |
10.8% vs. 1.4% RR: 7.7 12 Months |
||
| Olshen et al. (2007) 8080 New York City High School Students > = 14 Years 51% Female, 40.1% Hispanic, 36.0% Black, 16.0% Asian/other, 7.9% white |
(F) GLBU (All) |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: See Table Below For More Related Information. 3.7 (2.4-5.9) |
| (F) GLBU (All) |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
2.45 (1.31-4.56) Model Controls with Associated ORs: Dating violence (1.6), Feeling sad or hopeless (3.6), Disordered eating (1.8), Unsafe at school (1.9), Physical fighting (1.6), Binge drinking (1.9). |
|
| (M) GBU (All) |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
9.0 (5.3-15.3) |
|
| (M) GBU (All) |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
3.44 (1.88-6.32) Model Controls with Associated ORs: Sexual assault (3.9), Feeling sad or hopeless (4.3), Disordered eating (2.6), Drug use (2.3), Carried a gun (4.3). |
|
| Farley et al. (2008) |
GLBU (MF) |
Heterosexual (MF) |
31% vs. 8% Past 12 Months |
New York City: 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey See More Results: Table Below. RR: 3.9 |
| Other Studies |
Sexual
minority suicidality results from many other large scale adolescent
surveys - especially Youth Risk Behavior Surveys - have been reported
in
non-peer-reviewed venues such as reports and web pages. Some of these
results are given on another Web Page
and show that, generally, sexual minority adolescents are at increasing
risk for the more serious suicide behavior, compared to other
adolescents. Summaries of suicidality results for adolescent school
surveys are located here. |
|||
| ** Not Given. Estimated Made From Given Data. "RR" = Risk Ratio. "OR" = Odds Ratio All RRs or ORs are Statistically Significant, Except for "ns" = Not Statistically Significant. * M = Males - F = Females - *** YRBS = Youth Rsik Bhavior Survey |
||||
| New York City 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey; Grades 9 to 12 Suicidality, Past Year: Non-Heterosexual vs. Heterosexual 1 |
|||
| Categories / Variables |
Heterosexual % Incidence |
GLBU % Incidence |
Risk Ratio 2 |
| Seriously Considered Suicide |
14% |
37% |
2.6 |
| Planned Suicide |
10% |
29% |
2.9 |
| Atempted Suicide |
8% |
31% |
3.9 |
| Injured, Poisoned, or Overdosed in an Attempt |
2% |
9% |
4.5 |
|
Results are reported
to be similar in three New York City neighborhoods with high rates of
illness and premature death: East and Central Harlem,
Bedford-Stuyvesant and Bushwick, and the South Bronx. See Noyes et al. (2008).
1. Males & Females
analysed together, but differences possible/expected. All 'Race' groups
analyzed together, but differences possible/expected. All
Non-Heterosexual Students (GLBU = Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, Unsure)
analyzed together, but differences are possible/expected. See result
for NYC 2005 YRBS.2.
The counts are not given for populations or incidences. It is therefore
not possible to calculate confidence intervals and statistical
significance values. However, it can be assumed that differences are
statiscally significant.
|
|||
| 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey: New York City High Schools "Attempted Suicide" Risk: Same-Sex Sexual Orientation/Identity/Behavior vs. Others |
||||
| Study | Sexual Minority |
Others |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Grade - Age OR, (95% CI) Comments |
| Olshen et al. (2007) N = 8080 14 years and older 51% Female, 40.1% Hispanic, 36.0% black, 16.0% Asian/other, 7.9% white |
(F) Gay/Lesbian |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
0.9 (0.3-2.6) |
| (F) Bisexual |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
5.3 (2.9-9.8) |
|
| (F) Unsure |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
2.4 (1.1-5.4) |
|
| (F) GLBU (All) |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
3.7 (2.4-5.9) |
|
| (F) GLBU (All) |
(F) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
2.45 (1.31-4.56) Model Controls with Associated ORs: Dating violence (1.6), Feeling sad or hopeless (3.6), Disordered eating (1.8), Unsafe at school (1.9), Physical fighting (1.6), Binge drinking (1.9). |
|
| (M) Gay |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
6.2 (1.7-22.7) |
|
| (M) Bisexual |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
12.8 (6.5-25.3) |
|
| (M) Unsure |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
6.8 (3.3-13.9) |
|
| (M) GBU (All) |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
9.0 (5.3-15.3) |
|
| (M) GBU (All) |
(M) Heterosexual |
? Past 12 Months |
3.44 (1.88-6.32) Model Controls with Associated ORs: Sexual assault (3.9), Feeling sad or hopeless (4.3), Disordered eating (2.6), Drug use (2.3), Carried a gun (4.3). |
|
| Egan et al. (2007) N = 7,103 |
GB or Same-Sex Intercourse (M) Gay = 118 Bisexual = 101 |
Others (m) 3,538 |
- |
Those who were missing behavior and identity were excluded (N=374). "Significant differences were found between groups in reported tobacco, alcohol, and other drug use. Overall trends show that lesbian/gay/bisexual (LGB) youth were more likely to report ever using substances and increased alcohol use (days drank, binge drinking, age first used). Lesbian/bisexual girls and bisexual boys reported increased tobacco use (age first used, last 30-days, quantity). These data suggest that NYC LGB youth may face significantly greater risk for substance use than heterosexuals..." |
| LB or Same-Sex Intercourse (F) Lesbian = 132 Bisexual = 290 |
Others 3,565 |
- |
||
| Pathela (2008) |
See
the Powerpoint Presentation for the associations between same-sex
behavior and sexual identity and other sex related life events in the
New York City 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. . |
|||
| ** Not Given. Estimate Made From Given Data. "RR" = Risk Ratio. "OR" = Odds Ratio All RRs or ORs are Statistically Significant, Except for "ns" = Not Statistically Significant. * M = Males - F = Females - *** YRBS = Youth Rsik Bhavior Survey |
||||
| American Youth Risk Behavior Surveys: 2003 to 2007 Suicidality & Other Survey Results |
||||
| Categories / Information Sources |
Location, Year Sample Size |
Attempted Suicide, Past Year, % |
Related Information: Percentages For GLBU Odd Ratios (OR), 95% CI Other Related Suicidality Results |
|
| Sexual Minority |
Hetero- sexual |
|||
| Benbow (2005) Sullivan & Valles (2006) |
Chicago 2003 YRBS: 968 students in 23 public high schools. Grades 9-12 |
GLB 1 32% RR = 2.9 2 |
Hetero- sexual 11% |
GLB = 6.3%, 7.3% M, 4.7% F. 3 GLB = 7.3% Black, 5.8% Hispanic. 4.9% White. Same-Sex Sex = 2.3%, 1.6% M, 2.9% F. Depression: GLB vs. Heterosexual: 52% vs. 31% |
| Horn (2008) Horn (2007) |
Chicago 2005 YRBS: 941 students in 23 public high schools. Grades 9-12 |
GL: 27.3% B: 33.3% RR: 3.6-4.4 |
Hetero- sexual 7.5% |
GLB
= 4.2%. Unsure = 2.5% - GLB or Same-Sex Sex = 8.8% - African Americans
(52.6%), Latino (26.8%), White (9.5%), Asian (3.2%) and other (7.9%). Plan Suicide, Past year: 33.3% (GL), 35.0% (B) vs. 9.7% (Heterosexual). RR: 3.4-3.6 |
| VDH (200_) Outright Vermont (200_) VDH (2006) |
Vermont 2005 YRBS: 9,207-9,214 students replied to sexual orientation questions. All Students Surveyed: 9,342 from High / Middle Schools |
Same-Sex Sex: 42% GL: 32% B: 31% Unsure: 18% RR: 3.6-6.4 |
Opposite- Sex Sex: 9% Hetero- sexual: 5% |
Results Not Weighted. GL = 1.0%, B = 3.2%, Unsure = 3.0%, Same-Sex Sex = 2.6% Same-Sex-Sex. Females: Only With Females (0%), With Males & Females (2%). Males: Only With Males (0%), With Males & Females (1%). Results for many more "At Risk" behaviors are given in referenced document. Total Survey: 31,617 eighth to twelfth grade students in 146 schools representing 59 supervisory unions. |
| Outright Vermont (200_) VDH (2008) |
Vermont 2007 YRBS: 8,364 students: replied to sexual orientation questions. High / Middle Schools. Census for Vermont: 95.3% White, non Hispanic. |
GL: 27% B: 11% Unsure: 15%, RR: 2.8-6.8 |
Hetero- sexual 4% |
All: GL = 1.1%, B = 3.4%, Unsure = 2.8% Males: GL = 1%, B = 2%, Unsure = 2% Females: L = 1%, B = 5%, Unsure = 3% Same-Sex-Sex. Females: Only With Females (1%), With Males & Females (3%). Males: Only With Males (1%), With Males & Females (2%). Total Survey: 28,918 eighth to twelfth grade students in 144 schools representing 60 supervisory unions. |
| MCGLBTY (2003) |
Massachusetts 2003 YRBS: 3,624 Students, Grade 9 - 12 |
GLB 40.4% RR: 7.2 p < 0.05 |
Hetero- sexual 7.2% |
GLB = 3.5%. GLB or had Same-Sex Sex = 6.0% Attempted Suicide, Required Medical Attention: 18.3% vs. 2.2%, RR: 8.3, p < 0.05 |
| MCGLBTY (2005) |
Massachusetts 2005 YRBS: 3,522 Students, Grede 9 - 12 |
GLB 24.8% RR: 4.4 p < 0.05 |
Hetero- sexual 5.7% |
GLB = 3.7%. GLB or Had Same-Sex Sex = 6.4% Attempted Suicide, Required Medical Attention: 8.2% vs. 2.2%, RR: 3.7, p < 0.05 |
| MCGLBTY (2007) MDESE (2008) |
Massachusetts 2007 YRBS: 3,131 Students, Grede 9 - 12 |
GLB 29.1% RR: 4.5 p < 0.05 |
Hetero- sexual 6.4% |
GLB = 5.4%. GLB or Had Same-Sex Sex = 9.2% Attempted Suicide, Required Medical Attention: 12.1% vs. 2.2%, RR: 5.5, p < 0.05 White (72.8%), Hispanic/Latino (14.5%), African American (6.8%), Asian (3.1%), Others (2.9%). |
| Boulder County Public Health (2005) |
Boulder,
St. Vrain School Districts: 2003 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. 1,960 Students Grade 9 - 12 |
GLBU 44.0% RR: 3.3 |
Hetero- sexual 13.5% |
5.6% GLBU Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual + Unsure. White (81.2, 74.3%), Hispanic/Latino (10.9, 21.6%), Asian (5.4, 2.6%), Black (1.8, 0.9%), Native American (0.7. 0.7%). |
| Boulder County Public Health (2006) |
Boulder,
St. Vrain School Districts: 2005 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. 2,956 Students Grade 9 - 12 |
GLBU 23.6% RR: 3.7 |
Hetero- sexual 6.3% |
0.07% Gay/Lesbian, 3.6% Bisexual, 2.2% Unsure. White (72.1%), Hispanic/Latino (17.3%), Asian (4.1%), Black (1.6%), Native American (1.3%). Seriously consider suicide: 45.9% (GLBU) vs. 15.0% (Heterosexual), RR: 3.1 |
| Boulder County Public Health (2008) |
Boulder,
St. Vrain School Districts: 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. 2,106 Students Grade 9 - 12 |
GLBU 28.1% RR: 2.2 |
Hetero- sexual 12.5% |
89.0% Heterosexual, 1.5% Gay/Lesbian, 3.7% Bisexual, 2.3% Unsure, 2.3% None of The Above. White (74.0%), Other ? (13.5%), Others ? Seriously consider suicide: 49.7% (GLBU) vs. 14.1% (Heterosexual), RR: 3.5 |
| Rhode Island 2007 Youth Risk Behavior Survey. Tremblay (2009) 4 Note: Percentages Given Are Weighted Basic Results RIDHESE (2009): At Risk for 27 of 30 "At Risk" Behaviors |
All Students Heterosexual: 1,570 GLBU: 127, Raw Counts |
GLBU 33.8% RR: 4.8 |
Hetero- sexual 7.1% |
GLBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 4.4<6.3<9.1, p < 0.000, Weighted All Students: GL (1.9%), B (5.4%), U (2.7%) White (71.0%), Hispanic / Latino (16.7%), African American (8.7%), Asian (1.0%), American Indian (0.3%). Hawaiian/PI (0.3). Multiracial (2.1%) |
| All Males Heterosexual: 761 GBU: 55, Raw Counts |
GBU 26.2% RR: 4.2 |
Hetero- sexual 6.2% |
GBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 2.9<5.4<9.9, p < 0.000, Weighted All Males: G (2.5%), B (3.0%), U (2.4%) |
|
| All White Males Heterosexual: 493 GBU: 26, Raw Counts |
GBU 22.6% RR: 5.4 |
Hetero- sexual 4.2% |
GBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 2.7<6.6<16.3, p < 0.000, Weighted. White Males: G (1.7%), B (2.2%), U (2.7%) |
|
| All Other Males Heterosexual: 268 GBU: 29, Raw Counts |
GBU 31.0% RR: 2.8 |
Hetero- sexual 11.0% |
GBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 1.7<3.6<7.9, p < 0.000, Weighted. All Other Males = 96.3% Males Of Color. Males of Color: G (4.4%), B (4.5%), U (1.2%) |
|
| All Females Heterosexual: 806 LBU: 71, Raw Counts |
LBU 33.8% RR: 4.8 |
Hetero- sexual 7.1% |
LBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 4.2<6.7<10.7, p < 0.000, Weighted All Females: L (1.1%), B (7.7%), U (3.0%) |
|
| All White Females Heterosexual: 532 LBU: 45, Raw Counts |
LBU 36.9% RR: 7.1 |
Hetero- sexual 5.2% |
LBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 5.8<10.6<19.5, p < 0.000, Weighted White Females: L (1.0%), B (7.8%), U (2.9%) |
|
| All Other Females Heterosexual: 274 LBU: 26, Raw Counts |
LBU 25.6% RR: 2.2 |
Hetero- sexual 12.1% |
LBU vs. Heterosexual Counterpart, OR: 1.1<2.5<5.6, p = 0.022, Weighted. All Other Females = 94.4% Females Of Color. Females of Color: L (1.5%), B (7.0%), U (3.0%). |
|
| DCPS (2008) |
Washington DC 2007 Youth Risk Behavior. Survey. 1,783 Students: 1,532 replied to sexual orientation question. 1,523 replied to same-sex sex question. |
GLB 32.6% RR: 3.8% |
Hetero- sexual 8.6% |
Males: G (3.0%), B (4.1%), Not Sure (3.0%). Females: L (3.6%), B (6.3%), Not Sure (3.3%). Results likely weighted. Raw Counts given and give slightly different percentage results. Females report same-sex sex with females only (5.2%) and Males/Females (3.6%). Males report lifetime same-sex sex with Males only (4.9%) and Males/Females (2.0%). Demographics: African American (82.0%), Hispanic/Latino (10.8), White (5.4%), Asian/PI (1.6%), Others (0.2%) |
| WDPI (2008) Crabe (2008) GSASS (2009) |
Wisconsin 2007 Youth Risk Behavior. Survey. 2,094 Students Grade 9 - 12, 56 Schools |
Same-Sex Sex, Lifetime RR: 3.7 |
? |
Females report lifetime same-sex sex with females only (1.6%) and Males/Females (5.4%). Males
report lifetime same-sex sex with males only (2.0%) and Males/Females
(1.6%). Greater risk for having attempted suicide in the past year is
reported to be 3.7-times, but comparison group not stated. Could be "all others" or "only those who reported lifetime opposite-sex". Census: White, non Hispanic (85.4%), African American (6.0%), Hispanic / Latino (4.9%), Other (3.7%). |
| SFUSD (2008) ETRA (2008b) ETRA (2008a) |
San Francisco 2007 Youth Risk Behavior. Survey. 2,587 Students Grade 9 - 12, 14 Schools |
GLB 16% RR: 3.3 |
Hetero- sexual 5% |
LGBQ (11%): Males (10%), Females (13%). Gay/ Lesbian (1.8%), Bisexual (3.7%), Not Sure (5.8%). Transgender Demographics: All (1%), American Indian (20%), Hawaiian/PI (4%), Multiracial (4%), African American (3%), Chinese (1%), Filipino (1%), Other Asian (2%), Hispanic / Latino (0.4%), White (2%). School Demographics: Chinese (36%), Hispanic/Latino (19%), African American (12%), Filipino (6%), Other Non-White (13%), Multiracial (2%), White (9%). |
| 1. GLBUQ = Gay, lesbian, Bisexual, Unsure, Questioning. - 2. Risk Ratio. - 3. M = Males - F = Females 4. The Online Statistical Result Generator did not permit generating results for students of color: those who had specified their non-white 'race' or 'ethnicity'. Results were therefore generated for "All Other Students," meaning those not reporting to be white and those who did not specify their 'race' or 'ethnicity'. However, the majority in this category (> 94%) self-identified with a non-white 'race' or 'ethnicity'. |
||||
| Adolescent Public School Surveys: Random / Near-Random "Attempted Suicide" Risk: Same-Sex Sexual Behavior, Sexual Fantasies or Romantic Attraction vs. Opposite-Sex Behavior, Attraction, Fantasies |
||||
| Study | Sexual Minority |
Others |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Grade - Age OR, (95% CI) Comments |
| Eisenberg & Resnick (2006) |
402 (M*) Same-Sex Partners |
1,135 (M) Only Opposite Sex Partners |
29.0% vs. 12.6% RR: 2.3 Lifetime |
2004 Minnesota Student Survey N = 21, 927. Grades 9 & 12 Sex Partners: In The Past Year Males: OR = 2.5 (2.1, 3.0) Females: OR = 2.6 (2.2, 3.2) ORs: Controlling for Demography |
| 409 (F*) Same-Sex Partners |
2,559 (F) Only Opposite Sex Partners |
52.4% vs. 24.8% RR: 2.1 Lifetime |
||
| Pinhey & Millman (2004) |
? 24 (M) Gay, Bisexual |
? 650 (M) |
? 44.0% vs. ? 14.5% |
2001Guam Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS): Grade 9 to 12, 2.9% White Males, OR = 5.0 (2.1, 11.8) Females, OR = 2.6 (1.2, 6.0) Unadjusted ORs: No Controls Other Results & Estimate (?) Problems |
| ? 25 (F) Lesbian, Bisexual |
? 682 (M) |
? 52.0% vs. ? 27.4% |
||
| Robin et al. (2002) |
585 (MF) Same-Sex Partners, Ever |
6,873 (MF) Opposite Sex Partner, Only |
** 32.0% vs. 11.9% RR: 2.7 12 Months |
1995 & 1997 Vermont YRBSs, Combined: Grade 9 to 12 OR = 4.0 (2.9, 5.6), With Controls |
| 228 (MF) Same-Sex Partners, Ever |
3,948 (MF) Opposite Sex Partner, Only |
** 36.5% vs. 12.4% - RR: 2.9 12 Months |
1995 & 1997 Massachusetts YRBSs, Combined: Grade 9 to 12 OR = 4.9 (2.8, 8.7), With Controls |
|
| 585 (MF) Same-Sex Partners, Ever |
6,873 (MF) Opposite Sex Partner, Only |
** 17.8% vs. 4.5% - RR: 3.9 Medical Care |
Attempted Suicide Resulting in Having Received Medical Care Past 12 Months (Vermont) OR = 4.8 (2.9, 8.0), With Controls |
|
| 228 (MF) Same-Sex Partners, Ever |
3,948 (MF) Opposite Sex Partner, Only |
** 20.5% vs. 4.5% - RR: 4.6 Medical Care |
Attempted Suicide Resulting in Having Received Medical Care Past 12 Months (Massachusetts) OR = 5.0 (2.7, 9.3), With Controls |
|
| Russell & Joyner (2001) |
453 (M) Same-Sex RA/Re |
5,233 (M) |
5.0% vs. 2.0% RR: 2.5 12 Months |
National Longitudinal Survey of Adolescent Health (1994-95) Same-Sex RA (Romantic Attraction) /Re (Relationships) Males - OR = 2.45 (1.5, 3.9) Females - OR = 2.48 (1.7, 3.6) ORs: Controlling for Demography |
| 414 (F) Same-Sex RA/Re |
5,840 (F) |
12.2% vs. 5.0% RR: 2.4 12 Months |
||
| Faulkner & Cranston (1998) |
105 (MF) Same-Sex Partners, Ever |
1,563 (MF) Opposite Sex Partner, Only |
27.5% vs. 13.4% RR: 2.0 |
1993 Massachusetts YRBS: Grade 9 to 12 - RR's Are Significant, p < 0.05 All Suicide Attempts & Attempt(s) With Associated Medical Care Occurred During The Last 12 Months |
| 20.0% vs. 4.7% RR: 4.3 - Medical Care Related |
||||
| Barney (2003) |
65 (M) Same-Sex Sex Fantasies Obnly |
4,254 (M) Opposite-Sex Sex Fantasies Only |
23.2% vs. 11.1% RR: 2.1 |
1988 Adolescent Health Survey: Grade 7 to 12 -USA Indian/Alaka Native Reservations. RR: p < 0.01 Additional Results |
| Other Studies |
Sexual
minority suicidality results from many other large scale adolescent
surveys - especially Youth Risk Behavior Surveys - have been reported
in
non-peer-reviewed venues such as reports and web pages. Some of these
results are given on another Web Page
and show that, generally, sexual minority adolescents are at increasing
risk for the more serious suicide behavior, compared to other
adolescents. Summaries of suicidality results for adolescent school
surveys are located here. |
|||
| ** Not Given. Estimate Made From Given Data. "RR" = Risk Ratio. "OR" = Odds Ratio All RRs or ORs are Statistically Significant, Except for "ns" = Not Statistically Significant. * M = Males - F = Females |
||||
| 2001 Guam Youth Risk Behavior Survey Suicidality Results Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual vs. Other Adolescents Pinhey & Millman (2004) Study |
||||
| Categories |
N's All |
N's 1 Respon- ders |
Attempted Suicide |
Odds Ratios, (95%CI) Unadjusted / Adjusted |
| All (Ethnicities) |
1,381 |
? |
? |
|
| All Males |
674 | ? |
14.5% |
|
| Males: Gay & Bisexual |
24 2 |
? |
44.0% 3 |
Greater Risk for Attempting Suicide: Gay/Bisexual Males vs. Other Males OR = 2.45 (1.5, 3.9), No Controls OR = 5.1 (1.6, 15.5), 8 Control Variables |
| Males, Others |
650 2 | ? |
14.5% 3 | |
| All Females |
707 2 | ? |
28.2% |
|
| Females: Lesbian & Bisexual |
25 2 | ? |
52.0% 3 | Greater Risk for Attempting Suicide: Lesbian & Bisexual Females vs. Other Females OR = 2.48 (1.7, 3.6), No Controls OR = 2.2 (0.84, 5.6), 8 Control Variables, ns |
| Females, Others |
682 2 | ? |
27.4% 3 | |
| 1.
The number for students who responded to both the "sexual orientation"
and "attempted suicide" questions are not given. 2. Estimated from given proportion of student population that gay/bisexual (3.5% of males) and lesbian/bisexual (3.5% of females). Nonresponders likely and numbers may be less. 3. Estimated using given Ns (assuming no nonresponders) for population/subpopulation and numbers of attempters by using a a 2X2 Computation Table. That is, placing varying number estimates in 2X2 table to produce ORs for males and females (Attempted Suicide Risk, Sexual Minority vs. others, for each sex) that are as close as possible to the given ORs, without controls having been used to generate them. Ethnicity: 'Self-reported ethnicity consists of Chamorros (53.3% of the sample), Filipinos (25.9%), Asians (5.9%), Micronesians (7.2%), whites (2.9%), and other ethnicities (4.8%). The Asian category includes Chinese, Japanese, Vietnamese, and Korean respondents. The Micronesian category includes Chuukese, Yapese, Korean, Pohnpeian, and Palauan respondents. The ‘‘other ethnicity’’ category includes African Americans, Hispanics, and other Pacific Islanders.' (Pinhey & Brown, 2005) |
||||
| 1988 Adolescent Health Survey: Grade 7 to 12 USA Indian / Alaska Native Reservations |
|||
| Sexual Fantasies |
Opposite- Sex Only |
Same-Sex Only |
Both- Sex |
| Lifetime Attempted Suicide Incidence, Males |
11.7% (n = 515) |
25.0% (n = 17) |
10.9% (n = 21) |
| Lifetime Attempted Suicide. Incidence, Females |
25.2% (n = 925) |
15.1% (n = 14) |
16.8% (n = 83) |
|
Data Supplied by Borowski et al. (1999). Analysis for Same- vs. Opposite Sex Fantasies Males carried out by Barney (2003) who gives the "Sexual Fantasiy" question: “When you think or daydream about sex, do you think about males, females, or both?” Note: Bisexual males not at risk. Homosexual/Bisexual Females at l;esser Risk than Heterosexual Femnales. But replication studies never carried out since 1988. |
|||
| "Attempted Suicide" Risk: Random Samples, North America Homosexually vs. Heterosexually Oriented Adults |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odds Ratio (95% CI) |
| Bagley & Tremblay (1997) |
82 (M*) Homosexual, or Bisexual or Same-Sex Sex, Past 6 Months |
668 (M) Heterosexual, With No Same-Sex Sex, Past 6 Months |
6.1% (5 / 82) vs. 0.45% (3 / 668) Lifetime |
Calgary, Alberta, Canada Stratified Random Sample: 1992 Lifetime Attempted Suicide (Serious) Males, 18 to 27 years OR = 14.4 (3.4, 61.4) |
| Cochran & Mays (2000) |
78 (M) Reporting Lifetime Male Sex Partner(s) |
3,214 (M) Reporting Only Lifetime Female Sex Parters |
19.3% vs. 3.6% (Weighted) Lifetime |
USA: NHANES III Survey: 1988/94 Complex, multistage USA sample, civilian noninstitutionalized population. Subsample: Men, 17 to 39 Years OR = 6.45 (2.7, 15.2) OR = 5.36 (2.2, 13.0), With Demographic Control Variables |
| Gilman et al. (2001) |
74 (M) Reporting Male Sex Partner(s) Past 5 Years |
2,310 (M) Reporting Only Female Sex Partner(s) Past 5 Years |
(Weighted) Lifetime |
National Comorbidity Survey: 1992 Complex, multistage USA sample. Age = 15 to 54 Years. OR = 2.4 (1.0, 5.8), With Demographic Control Variables |
| 51 (F*) Reporting Female Sex Partner(s) Past 5 Years |
2,475 (F) Reporting Only Male Sex Partner(s) Past 5 Years |
(Weighted) Lifetime |
National Comorbidity Survey: 1992 Complex, multistage USA sample. Age = 15 to 54 Years. OR = 1.5 (0.7, 3.4), With Demographic Control Variables |
|
| Paul et al. (2002) Additional Results |
2,881 (M*) 93% Mostly Gay, Homosexual or Bisexual Identified MSM: Men Who Have Sex With Men |
None |
12%: Lifetime 8%: Before Age of 25 Years |
Random (Telephone): New York, Chicago, Los Angeles, San Francisco. Age Range: 18 to 70+ Years 75% of males first attempted suicide before the age of 25 years. |
| Cochran et al. (2007) N = 4,649 > = 18 Years Latino & Asian. National Household NLAAS Survey |
84 (M): GB Identified or Same-Sex Sex, Past year |
1,982 |
8.0% vs 2.3% Lifetime RR = 3.5 |
0.86<3.37<13.21 Weighted, With Controls, ns |
| 84 (M) | 1,982 |
2.4% vs 0.3 Past Year RR = 8 |
1.63<6.43<25.36 Weighted, With Controls |
|
| 161 (F) LB Identified or Same-Sex Sex, Past year | 2,271 |
8.5% vs. 5.2% Lifetime RR = 1.6 |
0.79<1.71<3.71 Weighted, With Controls, ns |
|
| 161 (F) | 2,271 |
2.4 vs. 0.6 Past Year RR = 4 |
0.84<4.98<29.33 Weighted, With Controls, ns |
|
| Silenzio et al. (2007) |
GLB 176 (M) 271 (F) |
Heterosexual & Mostly Heterosexual Identified 6,535 (M) 7,207 (F) |
4.9% vs. 1.6% Past Year |
National
Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health: 14,322 (MF). GLB = bisexual,
mostly homosexual, or exclusively homosexual identified. Age = 18 to 26 years. Attempted suicide in the past 12 months. OR: 1.4<3.0<6.2, controlling for race, gender, and age. |
| * M = Males - F = Females -- ** RR = Risk Ratio, Estimated - "ns" = Not Statistically Significant | ||||
| The Urban Men’s Health Study: 1996-98 Random Sample - MSM Suicidality - Paul et al. (2002) |
|||||||
| MSM: Men Who Have Sex With Men (Since Age 14) or Identified as Gay / Bisexual |
Total Sample, N = 2881 Age: 18 to 70+ Years |
Suicide Attempters n = 326 |
|||||
| Variables |
Frequency |
n1 |
Suicide Plan |
Attempted Suicide |
2Before Age 25? |
4Mean Number |
3Mean Age |
| All Males |
100% |
2,678 |
21% |
12% |
8% |
2.1 |
22.6 |
| White |
79% |
2,138 |
21% |
11% |
8% |
2.1 |
23.7 |
| African- American |
4% |
117 |
21% |
12% |
8% |
2.3 |
18.9 |
| Hispanic / Latino |
9% |
245 |
20% |
10% |
9% |
2.2 |
18.9 |
| Asian/Pacific Islander |
4% |
102 |
21% |
11% |
8% |
2.4 |
20.0 |
| Native American |
3% |
76 |
33% |
30% |
25% |
2.8 |
18.2 |
| Significance5 |
- |
- |
ns |
0.006 |
0.0002 |
ns |
0.06 |
| RR, Statistical Significance6 |
- |
- |
1.6 0.02 |
2.7 0.0000 |
3.1 0.0000 |
? |
Likely Significant |
| 1. The counts (n's) are not given in the paper but they are given by Mills et al. (2004) and would be an approximation. Therefore, all "n's" given in table are estimates. - 2. For having attempted suicide. - 3. For suicide attempts. - 4. For first suicide attempt. - 5. Significance for the suicidality variable and all 'race' groups. 6. - RR = Risk Ratio: Greater risk for Native American males, compared to White males. Significance for 2X2 RRs calculated from estimated n's.Statistically significant is: < 0.05 | |||||||
| "Attempted Suicide" Risks: Random Samples, Europe Homosexually vs. Heterosexually Oriented Youth/Adults |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odds Ratio (95% CI) |
| Wichstrom & Hegna (2003) Additional Results |
6.5% (MF*) 7.0%(F) 5.7% (M) Same-Sex Sexual Contact, Ever |
93.5% No Same-Sex Sexual Contact, Ever |
15.4% vs. 3.6% Lifetime RR: 4.3 |
Random Survey: Longitudinal 108 Attempters = 4.4%, N = 2,460 (In Regression Model) OR = 4.7 (3.1, 7.3), No Controls. OR = 4.3 (2.1, 5.6), With 6 Controls Variables |
| de Graaf et al. (2006) |
82 (M) Reporting Male Sex Partner(s) Past Year |
2,796 (M) Reporting Only Female Sex Partner(s) Past Year |
14.6% vs. 1.6% ** RR: 9.1 Lifetime |
Netherlands' NEMESIS Study Age = 18 to 64 Years OR = 10.23 (5.2–20.2) Control = Age OR = 5.57 (2.6–12.0) Controls = Age, Mental Disorders |
| 43 (F) Reporting Female Sex Partner(s) Past Year |
3,077 (F) Reporting Only Male Sex Partner(s) Past Year |
4.4% vs. 3.1% RR: 1.3 ns Lifetime |
Netherlands' NEMESIS Study Age = 18 to 64 Years OR = 1.52 (0.36–6.4) ns Control = Age OR = 0.96 (0.22–4.3) ns Controls = Age, Mental Disorders |
|
| Lhomond & Saurel- Cubizolles (2006) |
78 (F*) Reporting Lifetime Female Sex Partner(s) |
6,332 (F) Reporting Only Lifetime Male Sex Partner(s) |
25.2% vs. 6.6% Lifetime RR: 3.8 |
The Enveff (Enquête
nationale sur la violence envers les femmes en France, National Survey
on Violence against Women in France) Survey. ORs From: 4.8 (2.8–8.1)
to 2.2 (1.2–4.0) With Demographic Control Variable to All Possible Controls Variables. |
| 7.5% (7 / 78) vs. 0.3% (19 / 6,332) Past Year RR: 25.0 |
Attempted Suicide in the Past Year: OR = 32.8 (13.4, 80.4) Multiple Suicide Attempts, Lifetime: OR = 5.9 (3.1, 11.4) Note: Counts Estimated From Given Percentages. ORs are Estimates. Non-responders Likely. No Control Variables. |
|||
| 14.8% (11 / 78) vs. 2.7% (171 / 6332) Life, Multiple Attempts RR: 5.5 |
||||
| L’enquête Baromètre santé 2005 de l’INPES Results given in: MSJSVA (2008) |
2.9% (M) 1.5% Homo-Sex & 1.4 Bi-Sex n = 245?? |
Yes |
10.0% vs. 3.0% RR: 3.3 Lifetime |
16,883 Men & Women, Age Range = 15 to 75 Years Elsewhere, total number said to be 30,514 for age range 12-75 years (Site) Note: It would be important to know the distribution of GLB individuals and suicide attempters over the age range. For example, what would be the results in the 15 to 40 years of age category? GLB: deternined on the basis of having been sexually active with at least one member of the same sex, in the past year. GLB Demographic Summary. The Questionnaire |
| 1.4% (F) 0.6% Homo-Sex & 0.8% Bi-Sex n = 118?? |
Yes |
10.5% vs 5.9% RR: 1.8 ns Lifetime |
||
| L’enquête Baromètre santé 2005 de l’INPES Results Unknown For Youth |
Males |
Yes |
?? Lifetime, and in the Past 12 Months |
15-25 Years: Les Jeunes: The Questionnaire.
Some Reports are Done Separately For These Regions and are avaiable
online: Nord–Pas-de-Calais, Picardie, Pays de la Loire,
Champagne-Ardenne,
Lorraine, Poitou-Charentes, and L'Ile-de-France. Maybe Others? Data Sets could be grouped and the likely greater suicidality risks for homosexually oriented youth could likely be determined. Example: Westermann (2007), for Nord-Pas-de-Calais, N = 1,466, 5% of males had homo-sex in the past year (n = approx. 35), and 2% of females (n = approx 14). Blais et al. (2006), Pays de la Loire, N = 1,517, 4% of males had homo-sex in the past year (n = approx. 35), and 2% of females (n = approx. 15). A subsample of 100 is sufficient to so a suicidality analysis and more than 100 homo-sex males would be available if the data sets are integrated. |
| Females |
Yes |
?? Lifetime, and in the Past 12 Months |
||
| FHI Rapport (2005) |
(M) |
(M) |
See Tabled Results: 2005 National Public Health Survey, Sweden: Sexual Orientation & Transgender Related Suicidality. Results for Males & Females in Four Age Categories. |
|
| (F) |
(F) |
|||
| Hawton et al. (2002) |
82 Males: Worries about SO *** |
2,973 Males: No Worries About SO (Sexual Orientation) |
11.0% vs. 3.0% |
Representative Sample (N = 6,020): 16- to 17-Year-Old Secondary school Students Living in England. Data Collected in 2000-01. Lifetime Prevalence of Self-Harm: Boys (6.9%), Girls (19.9%) Greater Risk for Lifetime Self-Harm for Those Reporting Sexual Orientation Worries in Bivariate Analysis: OR, Boys: 2.0<4.0<8.3 OR, Girls: 1.6<2.7<4.3 No Contol Variables. Not Significant in Multivariate Analysis |
| 101 Females: Worries about SO *** |
2,590 Females: No Worries About SO (Sexual Orientation) |
23.8% vs. 10.5% |
||
| O'Connor et al. (2009) |
Males: Worries about SO *** |
Males: No Worries About SO (Sexual Orientation) |
?? Deliberate Self-Harm |
Representative Sample (N = 2,008): 16- to 17-Year-Old Secondary school Students Living in Glasgow, Scotland. Data Collected in 2006-07. Lifetime Prevalence of Self-Harm: Boys (6.9%), Girls (19.9%) Greater Risk for Lifetime Self-Harm for Those Reporting Sexual Orientation Worries in Multivariate Analysis: OR, Boys: 1.5<3.8<9.5 OR, Girls: 1.3<2.6<5.2 Using about 9 Contol Variables. Bivariate ORs: Not Given |
| Females: Worries about SO *** |
Females: No Worries About SO (Sexual Orientation) |
?? Deliberate Self-Harm |
||
| * M = Males - F = Females -- ** RR = Risk Ratio, Estimated - "ns" = Not Statistically Significant *** Somewhat of a proxy for having a homosexual orientation. SO: Sexual Orientation. |
||||
| Youth "Attempted Suicide" Risks: Norway Homosexually Oriented Youth |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odds Ratio (95% CI) |
| Wichstrom & Hegna (2003) |
6.5% (MF*) 7.0%(F) 5.7% (M) Same-Sex Sexual Contact, Ever |
93.5% No Same-Sex Sexual Contact, Ever |
15.4% vs. 3.6% Lifetime RR: 4.3 |
108 Attempters = 4.4%, N = 2,460 (In Regression Model) OR = 4.7 (3.1, 7.3), No Controls. OR = 4.3 (2.1, 5.6), With 6 Controls Variables |
| 20.9% (F) 8.6% (M) Some Same -Sex Sexual Attraction |
-- |
9.1% vs. 3.6% Lifetime RR: 2.5 |
ORs not Generated |
|
| 13.5% (F) 8.9% (M) Some GLB Identity |
-- |
9.1% vs.3.6% Lifetime RR: 2.5 |
ORs not Generated | |
| 7.0% (F) Same-Sex Sexual Contact, Ever |
93.0% No Same-Sex Sexual Contact, Ever |
19.4% vs. 4.2% From T-2 to T-3 ** RR: 4.6 |
N = 1,327 Females *** Predicting Suicide Attempt from 1994 to 1999: OR = 5.9 (3.2, 10.8), No Controls. OR = 5.0 (2.3, 10.6), 3 Controls |
|
|
* M = Males - F = Females
** Longitudinal Study, 3 Questionnaires from T-1 to T3: 1992
(T-1): 12,287 students, Grades 7 - 12. - 1994 (T-2): 9,679 students,
Grade 9 - 12+. - 1999 (T-3): 2,924 Youth.. - Mean Ages: 14.9 years (SD:
1.7, T-1) to 16.5 years (SD: 1.9, T-2) to 22.1 years (SD: 1.9, T-3).*** No Homo-Sex male suicide attempters from 1994 to 1999. Comparing the N's in both regression models reveals that there are only about 1,133 males (2460 - 1,327) available for analysis. Responders to "Attempted Suicide" and "Same-Sex Sex" questions: Males = 1,239; Females = 1,567: Total = 2,806, but the numbers are lower in regression analyses due to non-responses to other variables: 1,133 and 1,327 (Total = 2,460), respectively. Is An Estimate of the Percentage of Suicide Attempters Who are Homo-Sex Males Possible? Maybe not possible to calculate given the data supplied by the authors. Males & Females Reporting Homo-Sex, Ever: 2,806 X 6.5% = 182. For Females: 1,567 X 7.0% = 109.7 = 100. For Males: 1,239 X 5.7% = 70.6 = 71. Homo-Sex Males & Females Who Attempted Suicide: 182 X 15.4% = 28 Suicide Attempters. Homo-Sex Females Who Attempted Suicide from T-2 to T-3: 110 X 19.4% = 21 Suicide Attempters. This would mean that only a maximum of 7 Homo-Sex male suicide attempters could exist up to T-2, the number likely being less. Furthermore, it would seem that the great majority of Homo-Sex females who attempted suicide between T-2 and T-3 (All? Almost All?) are repeat suicide attempters. Assuming "All", this would mean that there are 7 Homo-Sex male suicide attempters, for an "Attempted Suicide" Incidence of 9.9% (7 / 71), all having occurred up to T-2. Unfortunately, the authors did not report any "Attempted Suicide" results specific to Homo-Sex males, other males, or all males up to T-2. The lifetime "Attempted Suicide" incidence for males is 2.2%; 1.6% for Non-Homo-Sex males from T-2 to T-3. |
||||
| 2005 National Public Health Survey, Sweden Sexual Orientation & Transgender Related Suicidality |
|||||
Categories |
Attempted Suicide, Ever % - Suicidal Thoughts, Ever [%] | ||||
| Transgender * n = 374 |
Males ** |
Females ** |
|||
| Homo-Bi |
Others |
Homo/Bi |
Others |
||
| 16 - 29 Years |
27% n = ? |
11% [47%] n = ? |
4% [14%] n = ? |
21% [53%] n = ? |
8% [21%] n = ? |
| 30 - 44 Years |
28% n = ? |
3% [30%] n = ? |
3% [12%] n = ? |
8% [17%] n = ? |
5% [14%] n = ? |
| 45 - 54 Year |
12% n = ? |
16% [21%] n = ? |
3% [9%] n = ? |
11% [25%] n = ? |
5% [13%] n = ? |
| 54 - 64 Years |
21% n = ? |
11% [33%] n = ? |
4% [12%] n = ? |
12% [27%] n = ? |
6% [16%] n = ? |
* Web Survey Data: Reported in National Public Health Survey, 2005. - ** National Public Health Survey, 2005. |
|||||
| "Attempted Suicide" Risks: Special Population Samples Homosexually vs. Heterosexually Oriented Adults |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odds Ratio (95% CI) |
| Herrell et al. (1999) |
103 (M*) Reporting Same-Sex Partner(s) Since Age 18 |
103 (M) Not Reporting Same-Sex Partner(s) Since Age 18 |
14.7% vs 3.0% Lifetime **RR: 4.9 |
USA: Vietnam Era Twin Registry 103 Twin Pairs, Discordant for Sexual Orientation OR = 6.5 (1.5, 28.8) More Related Information |
| 119 (M) Reporting Same-Sex Partner(s) Since Age 18 |
6,537 (M) Not Reporting Same-Sex Partner(s) Since Age 18 |
15.2% vs. 2.2% Lifetime RR: 6.9 |
USA: Vietnam Era Twin Registry N = 6,656 All Homosexual vs. All Heterosexual OR = 7.9 (4.6, 13.4) Calculated From Estimated Counts |
|
| Fergusson et al. (1999) |
29 (MF*) Gay, Lesbian or Bisexual Identified |
979 (MF) Heterosexual Identified |
32.1% (9 / 29) vs. 7.1% (69 / 979) RR: 4.5 |
Christchurch, New Zealand: Birth Cohort: At Age 21 Years Attempted Suicide: Age 14 - 21 Years OR = 6.2 (2.7, 14.3) |
| Skegg et al. (2003) |
427 (M) Reporting Any Same-Sex Sexual Attraction |
53 (M) Reporting Only Opposite- Sex Sexual Attraction |
17.0% (9 / 53) vs. 6.1% (26 / 427) RR: 2.3 |
Christchurch, New Zealand: Birth Cohort: At Age 26 Years Attempted Suicide: Lifetime OR = 3.2 (1.4, 7.2) (With Control Variables) |
| 119 (F) Reporting Any Same-Sex Sexual Attraction |
343 (F) Reporting Only Opposite- Sex Sexual Attraction |
12.6% (15 / 119) vs. 9.3% (32 / 343) RR: 1.3 |
Christchurch, New Zealand: Birth Cohort: At Age 26 Years Attempted Suicide: Lifetime OR = 1.4 (0.7, 2.7) ns (With Control Variables) |
|
| Fergusson et al. (2005) |
Christchurch, New Zealand: Birth Cohort: At Age 26 Years Attempted Suicide From age 21-25 Years. See Below. |
|||
| O'Donnell et al. (2004) |
31 (MF) Same-Sex Sex, Past Year |
848 (MF) No Same-Sex Sex, Past Year |
? % vs. ? % Males: 7.3% Females: 13% |
Longitudinal School Based Survey (USA): Grade 8 to Grade 11: 42.1% Male 68.6% African American, 16.5% Hispanic/Latino, 6.8% Black/Hispanic 2.7 (1.8, 6.6), with 9 Controls |
| Fergusson et al. (2005) |
Christchurch, New Zealand: Birth Cohort: At Age 26 Years Attempted Suicide From age 21-25 Years. See Table Below. |
|||
| McNair et al. (2005) |
8.6%, n = 801 Mainly Heterosexual to Lesbian |
91.4%, n = 8,482 Exclusively Heterosexual |
Self-Harm / Attempted Suicide Past 6 Months 11.1 - 17.3% vs. 2.7% |
Australian ALSWH Cohort Young Women in 2000 ORs: 4.3 to 8.0 (3 Control Variables) ORs: 3.1 to 5.3 (6 Control variables) Detailed Results: Table Below. |
| McNair et al. (2005) |
2.5% n = 261 Mainly Heterosexual to Lesbian |
97.5% n = 10,035 Exclusively Heterosexual |
Self-Harm / Attempted Suicide Past 6 Months 2.0 - 16.1% vs. 0.8% |
Australian ALSWH Cohort Mid-Life Women in 2001 ORs: 2.3 to 24.3 (3 Control Variables) ORs: 21. to 24.6 (6 Control variables) Detailed Results: Table Below. |
| * M = Males - F = Females -- ** RR = Risk Ratio, Estimated - "ns" = Not Statistically Significant | ||||
| Christchurch, New Zealand: Birth Cohort: At Age 26 Years Attempted Suicide From Age 21 to 25 Years by Sexual Orientation (Latent Class Determination) Fergusson et al. (2005) |
||||
| Heterosexual |
Predominantly Heterosexual |
Predominantly Homosexual |
p |
Risk Ratio* Ods Ratio |
| Males, N = 469 | ||||
| 93.7%, n = 439 |
4.8%, n = 23 |
1.5%, n = 7 |
||
| 1.6%, n = 7 |
0.0%, n = 0 |
28.6%, n = 2 |
<0.001 |
RR-1: 4.5<17.9<71.4 OR-1: 4.1<24.7<149.6 RR-2: 0.9<4.2<19.3 OR-2: 0.9<4.4<22.2 |
| Females, N = 498 |
||||
| 81.9%, n = 408 |
14.2%, n = 70 |
3.9%, n = 20 |
||
| 1.6%, n = 7 |
4.5%, n = 3 |
10.0%, n = 2 |
<0.005 |
RR-1: 1.3<5.8.<26.3 OR-1:1.2<6.4<32.8 RR-2: 1.2<2.4<4.8 OR-2: 1.04<3.4<10.9 |
| *Note: Only the percentages - NOT the counts - are given by study authors. Counts are Estimated from Percentages. RRs & ORs are approximate estimates given the estimated counts used in calculations. RR-1 & OR-1: Attempted Suicide: Predominantly Homosexual vs. Heterosexual RR-2 & OR-2: Attempted Suicide: Predominantly Homosexual &Predominantly Heterosexual vs. Heterosexual |
||||
| Australian Longitudinal Study on Women’s Health (ALSWH) Self-Harm & Attempted Suicide, Past 6 Months Young & Mid-Life Women: McNair et al. (2005) |
||||
| Categories |
n. (%) |
% Self-Harm / Attempted Suicide |
Odds Ratios 1 (3 Control variables) |
Odds Ratios 2 (6 Control variables) |
| Young Women: 22 - 27 Years of Age in 2000 |
||||
| Heterosexual |
8,214 (91.5%) |
2.7% (n = 222) |
Reference Category |
Reference Category |
| Predominantly Heterosexual |
604 (6.7%) |
11.1% (67) |
3.1<4.3<5.9 | 2.2<3.1<4.4 |
| Bisexual |
73 (0.81%) |
18.7% (13) |
4.1<8.0<15.8 | 2.5<4.8<9.3 |
| Predominantly / 100% Homosexual |
90 (1.0%) |
17.3% (16) |
4.3<8.0<14.7 |
2.9<5.6<11.0 |
| Percent of Young Women Who Self-Harmed or Attempted Suicide who are not 100% Heterosexual Women (8.5% of Young Women) |
30.2% (96 / 318) 3 |
All Non-Heterosexual Women, No Controls 4 4.0<5.1<6.6 |
- |
|
| Mid-Life Women: 50 - 55 Years of Age in 2001 |
||||
| Heterosexual | 9,676 (97.4%) |
0.8% (77) |
Reference Category | Reference Category |
| Predominantly Heterosexual |
121 (1.2%) |
4.0% (5) |
1.5<5.0<17.3 |
1.2<4.6<17.3 |
| Bisexual | 15 (0.15%) |
16.1% (2) |
3.6<24.3<163.9 |
4.1<24.7<148.6 |
| Predominantly / 100% Homosexual |
123 (1.2%) |
2.0% (2) |
0.42<2.3<13.0 ns |
0.38<2.1<11.9 ns |
| Percent of Mid-Life Women Who Self-Harmed or Attempted Suicide who are not 100% Heterosexual Women (2.6% of Women) |
10.5% (9 / 86) 3 |
All Non-Heterosexual Women, No Controls 4 2.2<4.5<9.0 |
- |
|
|
||||
| "Attempted Suicide" Risks: Other USA Random Studies Homosexually vs. Heterosexually Oriented Youth/Adults |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odds Ratio (95% CI) |
| Mathy (2002a) |
3,754 (M) |
25,652 (M) |
8.3% vs. 3.8% - Life: Self-Harm |
Sampling: News Web Site: MSNBC Every 1000th visitor: USA, Canada A Sexuality Survey Males, OR: 2.3 (2.0, 2.6) Females, OR: 2.1 (1.7, 2.5) Suicide Question: "I have made a serious suicide attempt or gesture." Yes/No |
| 1,048 (F) |
5,499 (F) |
17.1% vs. 9.1% - Life: Self-Harm |
||
| Reis & Saewyc (1999) |
331 Gay, Lesbian & Bisexual Identified |
7,146 Heterosexual Identified |
20.6% vs. 6.7% Past Year RR: 3.1 |
Seattle 1995 Youth Risk Behavior Survey Those "Unsure" of their Sexual Orientation Are Not Included Attempted Suicide: OR = 3.6 (2.7, 4.8) Attempted Suicide, With Medical Care OR = 4.6 (3.1, 6.9) ORs Calculated With Counts Estimated From Given Results |
| 9.4% vs. 2.2% Past Year Medical Care RR: 4.3 |
||||
| * M = Males - F = Females - RR = Risk Ratio |
||||
| Cornell University's "Survey of College Mental Health and Well Being" 1 Undergraduate Students: Cornell University & Princeton University 2 "Attempted Suicide" Risk: GLBQ vs. Heterosexual Identified Young Adults |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) GLB |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Age Odds Ratio (95% CI) |
| Whitlock & Knox (2007) |
63 Gay/Lesbian (MF*) |
2,632 Heterosexual |
?? Lifetime |
Web Survey, Random, Undergraduates at Cornell & Princeton University Appears like only gay & lesbian students are at significantly greater risk for having attempted suicide in lifetime: Adjusted OR: 1.2<4.2<14.1 3 Mostly Self-Injury & General Suicidality Analyzed. See Table Below. See also: Whitlock et al. (2006), but no relevant GLBT results are given. |
| 84 Bisexual (MF) |
2,632 Heterosexual |
?? Lifetime |
||
| 76 Questioning (MF) |
2,632 Heterosexual |
?? Lifetime |
||
| 1. The Survey: Related Informaton & Related Publications. - 2. Three other universities appear to be also involved in this survey: MIT, Harvard, and the University of Rochester. See: "College Mental Health Issues and Suicide-Prevention Program Discussed". 3.
The OR results from a logistic regression analysis with a control
variable (Self-Injury) that is a powerful predictor of "Attempting
Suicide" (5.4<9.6<17.1), controlling for demographic variables,
including sexual orientaton. It is possible that both bisexual and
questioning students were also significantly more at risk for having
attempted suicide, but that such significant ORs were driven to
insignificance by the aforementioned variable being present in the
regression, given that such students are at high risk for self-injury.
Nothing in this respect was mentioned by the authors. Counts or
incidences related to "attempting suicide" were
not given. Related ORs - GLBQ groups vs. heterosexual students -
with/without controlling demographic variables - were also not given.
Nonetheless, bisexual and questionning students remained more at risk
for "planning suicide" in a regression: AOR = 2.1<4.0<7.6. * M = Males - F = Females |
||||
| "Survey of College Mental Health and Well Being" Lifetime Self-Injury Behavior (SIB) & Suicidality: Undergraduate Students Cornell & Princeton Universities: Whitlock & Knox (2007) Raw Counts: Data Not Weighted 1 |
|||||||
| Category / Sexual Orientation |
SIB Only |
SIB & Suici- dality 5 |
Suicidality Only |
All SIB |
2 All Suicidality |
2 SIB or Suicidality |
No SIB / Suici- dality |
| "N" Totals Given: 2,875 |
292 |
196 |
227 |
488 |
423 |
715 |
2,160 |
| "N" Totals Sexuality N = 2,845 |
281 (9.8%) |
196 (6.9%) |
225 (7.9%) |
477 (16.7%) |
421 (14.7%) |
702 (24.6%) |
2,143 (74.3%) |
| Heterosexuality n = 2,632 [92.2%] |
256 (9.7%) 3 |
155 (5.9%) |
194 (7.4%) |
411 (15.6%) |
349 (13.3%) |
605 (23.0%) |
2,027 [93.8%] |
| Gay / Lesbian n = 63 [2.2%] |
7 (11.1%) |
5 (7.9%) |
9 (14.3%) |
12 (19.0%) |
14 (22.2%) |
21 (33.3%) |
42 [1.9%] |
| Odds Ratio 4 |
0.52<1.2<2.6 |
0.54<1.4<3.5 |
1.02<2.1<4.3 |
0.67<1.3<2.4 |
1.02<1.9<3.4 |
0.98<1.7<2.8 |
|
| X2 , p 4 |
0.13, 0.71 |
0.46, 0.50 |
4.2, 0.04 |
0.55, 0.46 |
4.2, 0.04 |
3.7, 0.05 |
|
| Bisexual n = 84 [2.9%] |
17 (20.2%) |
21 (25.0%) |
14 (16.7%) |
38 (45.2%) |
35 (41.7%) |
52 (61.9%) |
32 [1.5%] |
| Odds Ratio | 1.4<2.3<4.1 |
3.2<5.3<9.0 |
1.4<2.5<4.5 |
2.9<4.5<6.9 |
3.0<4.7<7.3 |
1.3<2.1<3.2 |
|
| X2 , p | 9.9, 0.002 |
49.0, 0.0000 |
9.9, 0.002 |
51.8, 0.0000 |
54.1, 0.0000 |
10.3, 0.001 |
|
| Questioning n = 76 [2.7%] |
11 (14.5%) |
15 (19.7%) |
8 (10.5%) |
26 (34.2%) |
23 (30.3%) |
34 (44.7%) |
42 [1.9%] |
| Odds Ratio | 0.82<1.6<3.0 |
2.2<3.9<7.1 |
0.70<1.5<3.1 |
1.7<2.8<4.6 |
1.7<2.8<4.7 |
1.7<2.7<4.3 |
|
| X2 , p | 1.9, 0.17 |
24.1, 0.0000 |
1.06, 0.30 |
18.9, 0.0000 |
18.0, 0.0000 |
19.4, 0.0000 |
|
| 1. An "added to" version of Table 1 in the Whitlock & Knox (2007) paper. 2. Columns added, via count additions from other columns. 3. Counts & Incidence. 4.
Odds Ratios: Compared to heterosexual students in same category.
Calculated by web page author (PJT) using the given counts. 5. Suicidality: Students reporting suicidal ideation, plan, gesture, or having attempted suicide. |
|||||||
| University of Michigan's 2005 / 2007 "Healthy Minds Study" Sexual Minority Results From a Presentation & Related Papers 1 |
|
| Eisenberg et al. (2006) |
Study results given at a symposium. 2,828
completed surveys, 56.3% response rate (48% for undergrads, 65% for
grad students), all results are weighted for non-response. In a list of
the "most prominent risk factors for mental health problems": "Bisexual
or gay/lesbian/queer (Depression and self-injury)". The intake queston
for "attempting suicide" in the past 4 weeks only produced one suicide
attempter, thus precluding this study from having any value in
exploring or understanding more serious forms of suicidality. "Between 3-4% reported suicidal thoughts in the past 4 weeks, and less than 1% reported plans for suicide." Note: It is possible (likely?) that those planning to commit suicide in the past 4 weeks, and especially those who attempted suicide in the past 4 weeks, may have been in a state of mind that would not be conducive to participating in a survey. |
| Eisenberg et al. (2007a) |
Some of the demographic data given in Table Below. "Self-identified
bisexual students were more likely to screen positive for depression
than self-identified heterosexual students": OR = 2.1<3.9<7.3,
from a regression analysis with many control variables. Similar
regression analyses do not reveal sexual minority students to be
significantly more at risk for depression, anxiety disorders, or
suicidal thoughts in the past 4 weeks. However, the low N's may have
compromised detecting such "at risk" status. See sexual minority N's in
Table Below. The sampling
representation for sexual minority undergraduates is poor (the worst
being only one undergraduate lesbian in the study sample), and the same
applies for the bisexual male representation for both graduate and
undergraduate students: 8 students each. |
| Eisenberg et al. (2007b) |
"...
multivariate logistic regression estimates of predictors of perceiving
a need for mental health services in the past year... reporting oneself
to be bisexual (relative to heterosexual, OR = 2.09, p = 0.03) or gay/lesbian (relative to heterosexual, OR = 2.04, p = 0.03)." |
| Gollust et al. (2008) |
"For
the full student population, we found no significant associations
between self-injury and age, international student status, sexual
orientation, graduate or undergraduate student status, or year in
school, controlling for all covariates. Logistic regression models,
which we estimated separately for male and female students, revealed
several notable differences in the predictors of self-injury...
Bisexual men (OR = 4.75, CI = 0.98-23.01, p = .053) and lesbians (OR = 5.52, CI = 1.80-16.9, p = .003) were more likely to report self-injury than were heterosexual students..." Alert: Many researchers in suicidology, and especially in sexual minority suicidology, have recognized that males and females should NOT
be analysed together, if it is at all possible to do otherwise. The
same applies within a sex group for the different sexual minority
groups. That is, when analyzed together, a significant "at risk"
association for only one group may be greatly reduced (as in being
spread over other groups), or even eliminated as the result of
non-associations in other groups. |
| Golberstein et al. (2008) |
Sexual minority students are not mentioned in the paper titled "Perceived stigma and mental health care seeking." |
| Cranford et al. (2009) |
In the paper "Substance
use behaviors, mental health problems, and use of mental
health services in a probability sample of college students," "sexual
orientation" is only mentioned to be a control variable in multivariate
analyses, with the related results are not reported. |
| Eisenberg et al. (2009) |
In the unpublished paper, "Mental health and academic success in college," sexual minority students are not mentioned. |
| Zivin et al. (2009) |
This study, 'Persistence of mental health problems and needs in a college student population,"
is longitudinal in nature, using a subset of students who completed the
first survey in 2005. "In the fall of 2007, all students who had
completed the baseline survey in 2005 and were still enrolled at the
university (N=1272) were asked to complete a two-year follow-up survey,
with a nearly identical set of measures. Of those re-contacted, 763
(60%) of students completed the second survey. The present study
examines data from these 763 students who completed both the 2005 and
the 2007 survey." There were 45 GLBT students (5.44% of students) in the 2007 survey. Sexual orientation (GLBT) is a control variable in multivariable logistic regression models but the GLBT results are not reported. |
| 1. Papers related to the Healthy Minds Study. |
|
| University of Michigan's 2005 "Healthy Minds Study" Some Demograhic Highlights, N = 2,843 |
||||
| Categories / Variable |
Undergraduates Weighted Percentages |
Graduates Weighted Percentages |
||
| Female n = 677 |
Male ** n = 504 |
Female n = 819 |
Male n = 843 |
|
| Age: 18 to 22 Years |
95.1% |
93.0% |
10.0% |
7.1% |
| White / Caucasian Non-Hispanic / Non-Arab |
68.6% |
68.1% |
56.5% |
53.9% |
| Asian / Pacific Islander |
15.0% |
15.9% |
24.4% |
30.8% |
| International Students |
4.3% |
6.9% |
16.3% |
27.3% |
| Heterosexual |
97.2% |
96.0% |
92.6% |
93.6% |
| Gay / Lesbian / Queer |
0.1% n = 1 * |
2.5% n = 13 |
3.2% n = 26 |
4.5% n = 38 |
| Bisexual |
2.6% n = 18 |
1.5% n = 8 |
3.6% n = 29 |
1.0% n = 8 |
|
Data Source: Eisenberg et al. (2007a). *
The n's are estimated from weighted percentages. Raw counts &
percentages are not given, except for the total male and female
numbers in the study sample. ** The "504" counts is reported to be "604" in the paper but that would be an error. See Gollust et al. (2008).
The representation of sexual minority students in this study sample is
generally poor, the worst being "one lesbian" representing lesbian
undergraduate students. Why there would be about 30-times more lesbians
in graduate school sample, compared to the undergraduate sample, is
food for thought.
Eisenberg et al. (2007b) - Weighted Demongraphic Summary: "The
results, weighted for nonresponse, reflect a population composed of
60.6% white (non-Hispanic), 6.3% black, 19.9% Asian or Asian-American,
3.5% Hispanic (any race), 5.4% multiracial, and 3.6% students who
identified some other race. Forty-eight percent were female, 11.8% were
international students, and 33.9% were graduate students. This student
population was roughly similar in demographic characteristics to the
national population of college students." Therefore, weighting would,
in many cases, radically change what were the raw counts, especially
for females, and for gaduate students.
|
||||
| The USA Spring 2000 National College Health Assessment Survey Depression & Suicidality: GLBT Results 1 |
|||||
| Study |
GLBT |
Hetero- sexual |
Depression Diagnosis 3 |
Seriously Considered Suicide, Past Year 3 |
Attempted Suicide Past Year 4 |
| Leino & Kisch (2005) |
n = ? (MF) < 479 2 |
n = ? < 14,711 2 |
GLBT vs. Heterosexual Odd Ratio: 1.4<1.8<2.4 - Lifetime 27 Control Variables % Depression All: 10.3% |
- |
- |
| n = ? (MF) < 479 2 |
n = ? < 14,711 2 |
GLBT vs. Heterosexual Odd Ratio: 1.2<1.8<2.7 - Past Year 27 Control Variables % Depression All: 6.1% |
- |
- |
|
| Kisch et al. (2005) |
n = ? (MF) < 479 2 |
n = ? < 14,711 2 |
- |
GLBT vs. Heterosexual Odd Ratio: 2.0<2.6<3.3 27 Control Variables % Consider... All: 9.5% |
? % Attempted... All = 1.47% Are GLBT Students More at risk? |
| The Attempted Suicide
Incidence for males in the past year: 1.59% = 88 Suicide Attempters.
But not all reported their sexual orientation, leaving about 85 Suicide
Attempters for analysis. It is 'roughly estimated that 7 or more
Suicide Attempters in the GBT male category (n = 208) would produce
statistically significan results. For 7 (incidence = 3.4%), the
unadjusted OR would be 1.0<2.2<4.8. For 8 (Incidence = 3.8%), the
OR would be 1.2<2.5<5.3. Counts Given in Table Below. |
|||||
| The Attempted Suicide Incidence for females in the past year: 1.40% = 126 Suicide Attempters. But not all reported their sexual orientation, leaving about 122 Suicide Attempters for analysis. It is 'roughly estimated that 7 or more Suicide Attempters in the LBT female category (n = 224) would produce statistically significant results.. For 7 (incidence = 3.1%), the unadjusted OR would be 1.1<2.4<5.1. For 8 (Incidence = 3.6%), the OR would be 1.3<2.7<5.7. Counts Given in Table Below. | |||||
| The Attempted Suicide Incidence for males & females in the past year: 1.47% = 214 Suicide Attempters. But not all reported their sexual orientation, leaving about 207 Suicide Attempters for analysis. It is 'roughly estimated that 7 or more Suicide Attempters in the GLBT category (n = 439) would produce statistically significant results.. For 12 (incidence = 2.7%), the unadjusted OR would be 1.04<1.9<3.4. For 13 (Incidence = 3.0%), the OR would be 1.2<2.0<3.6. Counts Given in Table Below. | |||||
| Note:
Kirsh et all (2005) did not mention whether or not GBT males, LBT
females, or GLBT individuals were more at risk for having attempted
suicide in the past year. 89.6% Undergraduate Students and 10.4% Graduate
Students are in the study sample. |
|||||
1. Data Set Results for the "Sexual Orientation" Categories & Depression / Suicidality are Given in Table Below. |
|||||
| The USA Spring 2000 National College Health Assessment Survey Sexual Orientation Demographics & Depression / Suicidality Results Depression / Suicidality Results For GLBT Students Are Not Given |
||||
| Categories / Variables |
Male n (%) |
Female n (%) |
Unknown n (%) |
Total N (%) |
| Which of the following best describes you? Question # 32 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
| Heterosexual |
5,151 (94.5%) |
8,510 (96.1%) |
1,050 (94.1%) |
14,711 (94.5%) |
| Heterosexual 'Sex Unknown" Removed |
5,151 (94.5%) |
8,510 (96.1%) | Removed |
13,661 / 14,100 96.9% |
| Gay / Lesbian |
136 (2.5%) |
69 (0.78%) |
16 (1.4%) |
221 (1.4%) |
| Bisexual |
70 (1.3%) |
147 (1.7%) |
19 (1.7%) |
236 (1.5%) |
| Trangendered |
9 (0.17%) |
8 (0.09%) |
5 (0.45%) |
22 (0.14%) |
| GBT, LBT, GLBT: 'Sex Unknown" Removed |
215 (3.94%) |
224 (2.53%) |
Removed |
439 / 14,100 (3.1%) |
| Unsure |
84 (1.5%) |
121 (1.4%) |
26 (2.3%) |
231 (1.5%) |
| Totals % of Sample [%] |
5,450 (100%) [35.3%] |
8,855 (100%) [57.4%] |
1,116 (100%) [7.2%] |
15,421 (100%) [100%] 1 |
| Depression Diagnosis, Ever. n / N (%) |
340 / 5,504 (6.2%) |
1,146 / 8,985 (12.8%) |
123 / 1,087 (11.3%) |
1,609 / 15,576 (10.3%) |
| Depression Diagnosis, In The Past year? Yes |
125 / 326: 38% 125 / 5,504 ? (2.3%) |
685 / 1,114: 61.5% 685 / 8,985 ? (7,6%) |
71 / 118: 60.2% 71 / 1,087 ? (6.5%) |
957 / 1,558: 61.4% 957 / 15,576 ? (6.1%) |
| Seriously Considered Suicide 1-2 Times, Past Year |
300 / 5,528 (5.4%) |
613 / 8,999 (6.8%) |
73 / 1,109 (6.6%) |
986 / 15,636 (6.3%) |
| Seriously Considered Suicide >2 Times, Past Year |
181 / 5,528 (3.3%) |
280 / 8,999 (3.1%) |
38 / 1.109 (3.4%) |
499 / 15,636 (3.2%) |
| Seriously Considered Suicide, Past Year |
481 / 5,528 (8.7%) |
893 / 8,999 (9.9%) |
111 / 1,109 (10.0%) |
1485 / 15,636 (9.5%) |
| Attempted Suicide 1-2 Times, Past Year |
43 / 5,528 0.78% |
96 / 8,999 (1.07%) |
12 / 1,108 (1.08%) |
151 / 15,635 (0.97%) |
| Attempted Suicide > 2 Times, Past Year |
45 / 5,528 0.81% |
30 / 8,999 (0.33%) |
14 / 1,108 (1.26%) |
89 / 15,635 (0.57%) |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year |
88 / 5,528 1.59% |
126 / 8,999 (1.40%) |
26 / 1,108 (2.34%) |
240 / 15,635 (1.53%) |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year "Sex Unknown" Removed |
88 / 5,528 1.59% |
126 / 8,999 (1.40%) |
Removed |
214 / 14,527 (1.47%) |
| Data Source: ACHA-NCHA (2000) 1. Total Survey: 16,024. 15,421 = 96.2% of Surveys. Percentages often given with more precision that in original document, using the given counts for calculations. |
||||
| Sexual Orientation Results From The Spring 2003 NYU American College Health Associaton National College Health Assessment |
||||
| General Information:
Fist Year New York University Students - 1,035 surveys returned -
Average age = 18.5 Years - 70% Females. 30% Males - 11% Self-Identified
Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual or Unsure Students (GLBU, n = 109). Note:
The counts are low, therefore likely statistical non-significance of
result differences for males and females analysed separately. Trends
nonetheless indicated that are consistent with results in other studies
of university students. A Student Presentation by Smith (2006). |
||||
| Category / Variable |
Males |
Females |
||
| GBU n = ? |
Hetero- sexual |
LBU n = ? |
Hetero- sexual |
|
| Depression Diagnosis, Ever? Question asked twice. |
17% 19% |
7% 8% |
43% 43% |
14% 15% |
| Depression Diagnosis, Past Year? |
11% |
3% |
18% |
7% |
| Anxiety Diagnosis, Ever? |
15% |
5% |
20% |
9% |
| Anorexia Diagnosis, Ever? |
8% |
< 1% |
6% |
5% |
| Seriously Considered Suicide, Past year, One to 11+ Times? |
26% |
15% |
25% |
15% |
| Attempted Suicide, Past Year, One to Two Times? 1 |
6% |
!% |
6% |
1% |
| Att | ||||