![]() |
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
To Gender Nonconformity & Transgender Issues |
![]() |
| Attempted Suicide, First Time: Homosexual vs. Heterosexual White/Black Males and Females, To Age 17 Years Bell & Weinberg (1978): Bay Area, San Francisco |
||||
| Category |
Incidence % (n / N) |
Risk Ratio* (95% CI) |
Odd Ratio* (95% CI) |
p |
| White Homosexual Males, n = 575 |
4.9% 28 / 575 |
13.8 (1.9, 101.1) |
14.5 (2.0, 107.0) |
0.000 |
| White Heterosexual Males, n - 284 |
0.35% 1 / 284 |
- |
- |
- |
| Black Homosexual Males, n = 111 |
11.7% 7 / 111 |
-- |
-- |
0.062 |
| Black Heterosexual Males, n = 53 |
0.0% 0 / 53 |
- |
- |
- |
| White Homosexual Females, n = 229 |
5.2% 12 / 229 |
1.1 (0.38, 2.9) |
1.1 (0.36, 3.1) |
0.913 |
| White Heterosexual Females, n = 101 |
5.0% 5 / 101 |
- |
- |
- |
| Black Homosexual Females, n = 64 |
6.2 % 4 / 64 |
0.79 (0.19, 3.3) |
0.78 (0.16, 3.8) |
0.751 |
| Black Heterosexual Females, n = 38 |
7.9% 3 / 38 |
- |
- |
- |
| All information calculated from information given in Bell & Weinberg (1978): Tables 21.14 & 21.15, pages 453-454. * Compared with heterosexual counterpart. |
||||
| Attempted Suicide, First Time: Homosexual vs. Heterosexual White/Black Males and Females, To Age 20 Years Bell & Weinberg (1978): Bay Area, San Francisco |
||||
| Category |
Incidence % (n / N) |
Risk Ratio* (95% CI) |
Odd Ratio* (95% CI) |
p |
| White Homosexual Males, n = 575 |
9.4% 54 / 575 |
13.3 (3.3, 54.3) |
14.6 (3.5, 60.4) |
0.000 |
| White Heterosexual Males, n - 284 |
0.7% 2 / 284 |
- |
- |
- |
| Black Homosexual Males, n = 111 |
11.7% 13 / 111 |
6.2 (0.83, 46.2) |
6.9 (0.88, 54.2) |
0.035 |
| Black Heterosexual Males, n = 53 |
1.9% 1 / 53 |
- |
- |
- |
| White Homosexual Females, n = 229 |
10.5% 24 / 229 |
1.8 (0.74, 4.2) |
1.8 (0.73, 4.7) |
0.186 |
| White Heterosexual Females, n = 101 |
5.9% 6 / 101 |
- |
- |
- |
| Black Homosexual Females, n = 64 |
9.4% 6 / 64 |
1.2 (0.31, 4.5) |
1.2 (0.28, 5.1) |
0.874 |
| Black Heterosexual Females, n = 38 |
7.9% 3 / 38 |
- |
- |
- |
| All count & results calculated from information given in Bell & Weinberg (1978): Tables 21.14 & 21.15, pages 453-454. * Compared with heterosexual counterpart. |
||||
Suicidality of White Predominantly Homosexual Males: First Time Suicide Attempts to Age 20 and After Age 20 - Bell et al. (1981) Data |
|||
|
Categories |
0 - 1 |
2 - 3 |
4 - 6 |
|
in Category |
(55/573) |
274/573 |
(244/573) |
|
Percent |
(12/55) |
(30/274) |
(12/244) |
|
To Age 20 |
(42/329) |
(12/244) |
|
|
After Age 20 |
(25/329) |
(26/244) |
|
| Calculations from
Data Set (Tremblay & Ramsay, 2002): Femininity to Masculinity Scale:
0 to 6
Greater risk (95% Confidence Intervals) for attempting suicide: 1. "0-1" F-M Category vs. this Category - RR = 1.1<2.0<3.6 (χ2 = 4.8, p = .027); 2. "0-1" F-M Category vs. this Category - RR = 2.1<4.4<9.3 (χ2 = 17.4, p < .0000); 3. "2-3" F-M Category vs. this Category - RR = 1.2<2.2<4.2 (χ2 = 6.3, p = .012); 4. "0-3" F-M Category vs. this Category - RR = 1.4<2.6<4.8 (χ2 = 10.1, p = .001); 5. "0-3" F-M Category vs. this Category - RR = .42<.71<1.2 (χ2 = 1.6, p = .20). See Note 2 for Odds Ratios. |
|
Gay And Bisexual Male Youth: Age 14 - 21 Years Remafedi, Farrow & Deisher (1991) |
|||
|
Categories |
|
Undifferentiated: 26% |
|
|
in Category |
(31/137) |
(42/137) / (35/137) |
(28/137) |
|
Percent Incidence |
(15/31) |
(23/77 = 30% ) 1 |
(3/28) 2, 3 |
|
Percent Incidence |
(38/108 = 35.2% ) |
(3/28) 4 |
|
| Bem Sex Role Inventory:
Feminine: High F, Low M scores- Masculine: Low F, High M scores
Androgynous High F & M scores - Undifferentiated: Low F & M scores Greater risk (95% Confidence Intervals) for attempting suicide: 1. "Feminine" Category vs. this Category - RR = .98<1.6<2.7 (χ2 = 3.3, p = .068); 2. "Feminine" Category vs. this Category - RR = 1.4<4.5<14.0 (χ2 = 9.8, p = .002); "Androgynous / Undifferentiated" Category vs. this Category - RR = .91<2.8<8.6 (χ2 = 4.0, p = .044); 4. "Feminine / Androgynous / Undifferentiated" Category vs. this Category - RR = 1.1<3.3<9.9 (χ2 = 6.3, p = .012). See Note 3 for Odds Ratios |
| "Attempted Suicide" Incidences/Risks Transgender (TG) Populations |
||||
| Study |
Sample Size (N) TG |
Compa- rison Group |
Attempted Suicide % (n / N) |
Sampling Information Risk Ratio, p Odd Ratios, Specified |
| Xavier (2000) Washington D.C. |
252 *MTF: 189 |
None |
16% |
70% African-American, 22% Latino/a, 8% Others. Age Range: 13 to 61 Years Nearly 80% = 36 years and under |
| ** Nemoto (2001) San Francisco |
MTF: 245 |
None |
32% |
MTF Of Color |
| ? |
51% |
African American |
||
| ? |
31% |
Latina |
||
| ? |
18% |
Asian / Pacific Islander | ||
| Nemoto et al. (2002) San Francisco |
MTF: 332 |
None |
29% |
MTF Of Color ***8 |
| 112 |
41% |
African American - Mean Age: 36.5*** | ||
| 110 |
45% |
Latina - Mean Age: 32.9 | ||
| 110 |
15% |
Asian/Pacific Islander - Mean Age: 32.9 | ||
| Mathy (2002b) Additional Results North American |
73 TG 61 TG = Canadians 12 TG = Americans |
1,083 |
23.3% vs 11.4% |
TG vs. Random Heterosexual Females 2.9, p < .01 |
| 1,077 |
23.3% vs 5.0 |
TG vs. Random Heterosexual Males 4.7, p < .001 |
||
| 73 |
23.3% vs 11.0% |
TG vs. Matched Females 2.1, p < .05 |
||
| 73 |
23.3% vs 4.1% |
TG vs. Matched Males 5.7, p < .001 |
||
| 256 |
23.3% vs 16.0% |
TG vs. Random Homosexual Females 1.5, ns |
||
| 356 |
23.3% vs 8.7% |
TG vs. Random Homosexual Males 2.7, p < .001 |
||
| Kenagy (2005) Philadelphia |
All MTF: 182 |
None |
30.1% | Volunteers: Face-to-Face Interview or Questionnaire - 41.3: African American, 33.0% white, 10.1% multiracial, 6.1& Hispanic, 5.6% biracial, 3.9% others. See also: Kenagy (1998) |
| MTF: 113 |
32.4% |
|||
| * FTM: 69 |
26.2% |
|||
| Operario & Nemoto (2005) San Francisco |
MTF: 110 Asian Pacific Islanders |
None |
15% Same Sample as in Nemoto et al. (2002) |
Volunteers: San Francisco **** Mean Age: 33, Range: 18 to 57 Years 46% of FTM = Filipino, 9% Laotian, 7% Vietnamese, 4% Hawaiian, remainder identifying as other Asian/PI ethnicities. |
| Clements- Nolle et al. (2006) San Francisco Additional Results |
All TG: 515 |
None |
32.2% |
63.7% Non-White, 36.3% White |
| MTF: 391 |
MTF vs. FTM |
32.5% |
OR = 1.04 (0.67, 1.6) ns, No Controls OR = 1.1 (0.59, 1.9), 9 Controls |
|
| FTM: 123 |
31.7% |
|||
| White: 188 |
White vs. Non- White |
37.8% | OR = 1.5 (1.02, 2.2), No Controls OR = 1.5 (0.92, 2.4), 9 Controls |
|
| Others: 323 |
28.8% |
|||
| < 25 Yrs: 66 |
< 25 vs 25 + Yrs |
47.0% |
OR = 2.1 (1.2, 3.5), No Controls OR = 2.17 (1.17, 4.01), 9 Controls |
|
| 25+ Yrs: 449 | 30.1% | |||
| Zians (2006) |
TG: 136 |
None |
17.6% (24 / 136) |
San Diego, California Mean Age: 38.3 (SD: 13.1) Age Range: 9 to 79 Years 48.3% White, 16.2% Latino, 14% African American, 10.3% Biracial |
| Kim et. al. (2006) |
MTF: 43 |
49 Matched non-FTMs |
62.8% (27 / 43) |
Presenting at compulsory military service in 3 Korean Cities. Age Range: 19 to 23 Years |
| Taylor (2006) |
TG: 73 |
None |
28% |
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada 49 Born Male, 21 Born Female, 3 Intersexed. 20 Aboriginal Age Range: 18 to 60+ |
| * MTF: Male to Female - FTM: Female to Male ** The Nemoto (2001) Study Sample is Likely a Subset of Nemoto et al. (2002) Study Sample. *** Mean Ages are from Nemoto et al. (2004). **** Face-to-Face Interviews. |
||||
| The Mathy (2002b) Study of Transgender Suicidality North America: Internet Survey |
|||||||
| Categories |
TG |
Random Heterosexual |
Matched |
Homosexual | |||
| Gender * |
TG |
F |
M |
F |
M |
F |
M |
| N's |
73 |
1,083 |
1,077 |
73 |
73 |
256 |
356 |
| Mean Age SD Age Range |
36.9 (10.0) 19-58 |
30.1 (9.3) 18-76 |
33.7 (11.0) 18-80 |
36.0 (9.8) 19-53 |
37.0 (10.0) 19-56 |
33.7 (8.9) 18-69 |
33.0 (9.7) 18-70 |
| Attempted Suicide / Self-Harm ** |
23.3% |
11.4% |
5.0% |
11.0% |
4.1% |
16.0% |
8.7% |
| *** Risk Ratio: TG vs. Specified Category |
2.9 |
4.7 |
2.1 |
5.7 |
1.5 |
2.7 |
|
| p | < .01 |
< .001 |
< .05 |
< .001 |
ns |
< .001 |
|
| * TG = Transgender - M = Males - F = Females -- *** Not Given in Mathy (2002b) ** Suicide Question: "I have made a serious suicide attempt or gesture." Yes/No Sampling: News Web Site: MSNBC - Every 1000th visitor: USA, Canada - A Sexuality Survey Using mostly counts from random sample, but also from volunteer sample. TG (Transgender) Sample: N = 73, 61 Canadian, 12 American, with 12 / 73 from random sample. |
|||||||
| The Clements-Nolle et al. (2006) Study of Suicidality* In The San Francisco Transgender Population |
|||
| Categories |
Attempted Suicide Lifetime: % (n / n) |
Odds Ratio (95%CI) Unadjusted ** |
Odds Ratio (95%CI) Adjusted |
| All, N = 515 |
32.2% (166 / 515) |
||
| MTF, n = 391 Male-to-Female |
32.5% (127 / 391) |
1.04 (0.67, 1.6) ns |
1.1 (0.59, 1.9) Controls: 9 Variables |
| FTM, n = 123 Female-to-Male |
31.7% (39 / 123_ |
||
| White |
37.8% (71 / 188) |
1.5 (1.02, 2.2) p = 0.036 |
1.5 (0.92, 2.4) Controls: 9 Variables |
| Non-White |
28.8% (93 / 323) |
||
| < 25 Years-Old |
47.0% (31 / 66) |
2.1 (1.2, 3.5) p = 0.006 |
2.17 (1.17, 4.01) Controls: 9 Variables |
| 25 + Years-Old |
30.1% (135 / 449) |
||
| Volunteers Interviewed. 37% White, 23% Black, 23% Latino/a, 11% Asian/PI, 5% Native American Median Age: 34, Age Range: 18 to 67 Years The "Attempted Suicide" 32% Lifetime Incidence was First Reported by Clements-Nolle et al. (2001) ** Odds Ratios Not Given. Calculated From Given Counts |
|||
| Transgender and Transsexual People in Sweden An Internet Sample, N = 374 * |
|
| Age Group |
Attempted Suicide, Lifetime |
| 16 - 29 Years |
27%, n = ? |
| 30 - 44 years |
28%, n = ? |
| 45 - 54 years |
12%, n = ? |
| 55 - 64 Years |
21%, n = ? |
| * Web Survey Data: Reported in National Public Health Survey, 2005. For comparison of Transgender Suicidality results to GLB & HeterosexualResults, See Table. |
|
| Transgender and Transsexual People in the United Kingdom An Internet Sample, N = 872** |
|
| Frequency |
Attempted Suicide / Self-Harmed in Adulthood* |
| Once |
14% |
| Twice |
7% |
| Three or More Tmes |
14% |
| One or More Times |
34.4% |
|
*Resulting from being a crossdresser, transgender/transsexual person or because of other people’s reactions to them being trans.
Data Source: Whittle et al. (2007)Note: Data was solicited on suicdality before the age of 21 years, but the results were not reported. In Whittle et al. (2008), the incidence in this category was reported to be also 34%. ** Sample may include duplicates? |
|
| Transgender and Transsexual People in Europe An Internet Sample, N = 985 (UK = 322)** |
|
| Frequency |
Attempted Suicide / Self-Harmed in Adulthood* |
| Once |
? |
| Twice |
? |
| Three or More Tmes |
? |
| One or More Times |
29.9% |
|
*Resulting from being a crossdresser, transgender/transsexual person or because of other people’s reactions to them being trans.
Data Source: Whittle et al. (2008)Note: Data was solicited on suicdality before the age of 21 years, but the results were not reported. ** Duplicates Removed. |
|
Bell A, Weinberg M, Hammersmith S (1981). Sexual Preference: Its Development in Men and Women. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press.
Bell A, Weinberg M, Hammersmith
S (1981). Sexual Preference: Statistical Appendix. Bloomington,
Indiana: Indiana University Press.
Bergling, Tim (2001). Sissyphobia: Gay Men and Effeminate Behavior. New York: Harrington Park Press. Internet: http://www.timbergling.com/sissyphobia/ - Excerpt: Amazon.com. Book Review.
Clements-Nolle KD (2001). HIV Prevalence, Risk Behaviors and Attempted Suicide in a Hidden Population: Results From the Transgender Community Health Project. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of California, Berkeley. Full Text available from UMI ProQuest Digital Dissertations.
Clements-Nolle K, Marx R, Guzman R, Katz M (2001).
HIV prevalence, risk behaviors, health care use, and mental health
status of transgender persons: implications for public health
intervention. American Journal of Public Health, 91(6): 915-21. PubMed Abstract. Full Text.
Friedman MS, Koeske GF, Silvestre AJ, Korr WS, Sites EW (2006). The impact of gender-role nonconforming behavior, bullying, and social support on suicidality among gay male youth. Journal of Adolescent Health, 38(5): 621-3. PubMed Abstract.
Friedman MS (2002). Gender Role Nonconformity, Bullying and Suicidality Among Gay and Bisexual Male Adolescents. Ph.D. Dissertation. School of Social Work, University of Pittsburgh. Full Text available from UMI ProQuest Digital Dissertations.
Harry J (1983a). Parasuicide, gender, and gender deviance. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 24(4): 350-61. PubMed Reference. Abstract.
Kenagy GP (2005). Transgender Health: Findings from Two Needs Assessment Studies in Philadelphia. Health and Social Work, 30(1): 19-26. PubMed Abstract. Full Text.
Nemoto T, Keatley J, Operario D, Soma T (2002). Psychosocial Factors affecting HIV Risk Behaviors among Male to Female transgenders in San Francisco. Poster # WePeE6583, presented at the XIV International AIDS Conference in Barcelona, Spain, July 2002. Internet: http://www.hawaii.edu/hivandaids/Psychosocial%20Factors%20Affecting%20HIV%20Risk%20Behaviors%20Among%20MTF%20Transgenders.pdf .
Nemoto T, Operario D, Keatley J, Han L, Soma T (2004). HIV risk behaviors among male-to-female transgender persons of color in San Francisco. American Journal of Public Health, 94(7): 1193-9. PubMed Abstract. Full Text.
Nemoto (2001). Study results reported in "TRANS Research," Center For AIDS Prevention Studies. Internet: http://caps.ucsf.edu/projects/TRANS/transresearch.php .
Operario D, Nemoto T (2005). Sexual risk behavior and substance use among a sample of Asian Pacific Islander transgendered women. AIDS Education and Prevention, 17(5): 430-43. PubMed Abstract.
Remafedi G, Farrow JA, Deisher RW (1991). Risk factors for attempted suicide in gay and bisexual youth. Pediatrics, 87(6): 869-75. PubMed Abstract.
Taylor (2006). Nowhere Near
Enough: A Needs Assessment of Health and Safety Services for
Transgender and Two Spirit People in Manitoba and Northwestern
Ontario. Winnipeg, Manitoba. Internet:
http://www.turtleisland.org/healing/transgender.doc . Executive Summary
and Download Page:
http://www.turtleisland.org/discussion/viewtopic.php?p=7927 .
Tremblay P, Ramsay R (2002). Statistical
results generated via SPSS-10 by Thomas G. Albright, Systems Analyst/Programmer
at the Kinsey Institute for Research in Sex, Gender and Research. January
9 and 11, 2002.
Whittle S, Turner L, Al-Alami M (2007). Engendered Penalties: Transgender and Transsexual People’s Experiences of Inequality and Discrimination. Manchester Metropolitan University. A Research Project and Report Commissioned by the Equalities Review. PDF Download. PDF Download.
Whittle S, Turner L, Combs R, Rhodes s (2008). Transgender EuroStudy: Legal Survey and Focus on the Transgender Experience of Health Care. Brussels, Belgium: ILGA-Europe: The European Region of the International Lesbian and Gay Association. Download Page. PDF Download.